Hadith/Narration
A man at the grave of RasoolAllah ﷺ said :
❝O Messenger of Allah [Ya RasoolAllah ﷺ], ask Allah to send rain for your community [Ummah], for they are being destroyed.❞
Complete Hadith/Narration :
Abu Muawiyah narrated to us, from al-Amash, from Abu Salih, from Malik al-Dar, who said:
"I was the keeper of Umar's food stores. During the time of Umar, the people were afflicted by a drought. A man came to the grave of the Prophet and said: 'O Messenger of Allah, ask Allah to send rain for your community, for they are being destroyed.'
Then the man saw in a dream, and it was said to him: 'Go to Umar, convey my salām to him, and inform him that they will be given rain. And tell him: Be wise, be wise!' So he went to Umar and informed him. Umar wept and said: 'My Lord, I spare no effort except in that which is beyond my ability."
📚 Al-Musannaf Ibn Abi Shaybah, Volume 11, Page No. 118, Hadith no. 32538
1. The Blazing Star : In Defence Of A Narration From Malik Al-dar [Link]
— by Dr. Abul Hasan Hussain Ahmed [Darul Tahqiq]
2. Rafal-Manarah [Link]
— by Sheikh Mehmood Saeed
3. Our own Research and Arguments
Chain of Narration [Isnad] :
→ Abu Muawiyah
→ al-Amash
→ Abu Salih
→ Malik al-Dar
Response —
This is a baseless argument
He is not Majhul [Unknown]. On the contrary, he was very well known, Senior Tabi of Madina, Freed slave of Umar ibn al-Khattab and his Treasurer
Following are mentioned as Identification of Malik al-dar
1) Musannaf Ibn Abi Shaybah [d.235 AH] :
• Treasurer of Umar
📚 Al-Musannaf Ibn Abi Shaybah, Volume 11, Page No. 118, Hadith no. 32538
2) Imam Ibn Sa'd [d. 230 AH] :
• First layer of Successors [ Senior Tabi’in] among people of Madina
• Freed slave of Umar ibn al-Khattab
• He narrated on the authority of Abu Bakr and Umar
• Abu Salih al-Samman narrated on his authority
• He was well-known
📚 Kitab al-Tabaqat 7/12, 1423
3) Imam ibn Asakir [d. 571 AH]
• Mentioned the same report from Ibn Sa’d with his own chain of transmission
📚 Tarikh Madinat Dimashq 56/492
4) Imam Dhahabi [d. 748 AH] :
See More Identification in the next section [Objection 2]
Objection 2️⃣ : Malik al-Dar Is Majhul al-hal [Unknown Reliability]
Majhul here means, we know his identity however we don't know whether he was thiqah [Trustworthy] / Reliable as narrator or not hence his narration is rejected
Imam al-Haythami and Imam al-Mundhiri both commented on a different narration of Malik al-dar and and did Jarah [Criticism], they said Malik al-dar is Majhul, means Majhul al-hal
Response —
This is a clear lie
Let me show you the scan of their Statements
Imam al-Haythami :
• As for Malik al-Dar, I do not know him [lam a'rifhu لم أعرفه], but the rest of its narrators are trustworthy
📚 Majma al-Zawaid 7/240, 4747
Imam al-Mundhiri :
• Its narrators up to Malik al-Dar are trustworthy and famous, but I do not know [la a'rifhu لا أعرفه], Malik al-Dar
📚 Targhib wa al-Tarhib 1/399, 1326
Al-Mundhiri and al-Haythami said “La Arifuhu” (I do not know him), not “Majhul” (unknown/unreliable narrator). This is not Jarah by any way or form. Their lack of knowledge does not establish that Malik al-Dar was unknown or unreliable
Prominent scholars, including Ibn Sa'd, Abu Yala al-Khalili, Ibn Asakir, Ibn Hibban, Ibn Hajar, al-Dhahabi, etc knew of him [see next sections]. It is therefore questionable that Albani preferred the opinions of those unfamiliar with Malik al-Dar over those of scholars who knew him
Now as for the claim of Majhul al-hal
Imam Ibn Hajar :
Majhul al-Hal [Al-Mastur] -
“If two or more people narrate from a narrator, but he has not been declared trustworthy (thiqa), then he is majhul al-hal, and he is the mastūr (one whose condition is concealed).” A group of scholars accepted his narration without qualification, while the majority rejected it. The correct and thoroughly investigated position is that the narration of the mastur and those similar to him, whose status remains uncertain, should neither be categorically declared rejected nor categorically accepted. Rather, it should be said that his narration remains suspended until his condition becomes clear, as Imam al-Ḥaramayn decisively stated
📚 Sharh Nukhbat al-Fikar fi Mustalah Ahl al-Athar 1/98
Second things is that, the condition for Majhul-al-Hal, is that, he has not been declared trustworthy (thiqa), However Imam Ibn Hibban declared Malik al-dar as Trustworthy Hence he is no longer Majhul al-hal and we will also prove how Imam Ibn Hibban was not Lenient on his Authentication [See next Section]
Tawthiq [Authentication] Of Malik al-Dar
1) Imam Ibn Hibban [d. 354 AH] :
• Mentioned Malik al-Dar in his Kitab al-Thiqat [Trustworthy]
• Malik [ibn Ayad] al-Dar narrates from Umar ibn al-Khattab. Abu Salih al-Samman narrated from him, and he was a freed slave of Umar ibn al-Khattab, originally from Jabalan
📚 Kitab al-Thiqat 5/384
2) Imam Abu Yala al-Khalili [d. 446 AH] :
• Malik al-Dar, the freed slave of Umar ibn al-Khattab
• An early Tabi'in, agreed upon [Muttafaq `alayh] - Upright and Reliable
• The Tabi'n praised him [Athna `alayhi al-tabi`un]
📚 al-Irshad 1/313
Note - The comment of Abu Yala is indeed an Authentication of Malik al-dar. See expaination of Imam Ibn Hajar under Section 6 [Investigation of Malik al-Dar
Objection 3️⃣ : Imam Ibn Hibban Was Mutasahil [Lenient]
Response —
Indeed, Imam Ibn Hibban has been labelled as Mutasahil [Lenient] when it comes to Authentication, but this at all doesn't mean that all of his Authentication is due to his Leniency and it's rejected
Even a little investigation of Malik al-dar clearly shows that he was not lenient on Malik al-dar and his Authentication is Valid and acceptable [see section Investigation of Malik al-dar]. This is why All the scholars who graded this narration of Malik al-dar, graded it SAHIH [Authentic]
Before going on to the next section let me show you something
> Bonus : Hypocrisy of Albani
1) Albani commented on authentication of a Narrator Ruh ibn Salah by Imam Ibn Hibban and Hakim and said :
• Ibn Hibban is lenient in declaring narrators trustworthy, for he frequently declares unknown narrators trustworthy...Al-Hakim is similarly lenient, as is evident to one well-versed in the science of biographies and narrators. "THEREFORE, WHEN THEIR STATEMENTS CONFLICT [WITH THE CRITICISM OF OTHER SCHOLARS], THEIR STATEMENTS ARE NOT GIVEN ANY WEIGHT, EVEN IF THE CRITICISM IS UNEXPLAINED [GHAYR MUFASSAR]
📚 Silsilat al-Ahadith al-Da'if 1/80
Note - Albani’s criticism is specifically in the case of contradiction. Therefore, it is clear from his wording that when there is no contradiction, he does not deny weight to Ibn Hibban’s authentication
However he deemed this narration Weak, even when Ibn Hibban's authentication has no contradiction whith any other scholar
And If there is any conflicting criticism from even a single rijal scholar [not modern], then bring it to us. However Objectors can't, because it doesn't exists
2) Albani [d. 1420 AH] was the one who raised this objection [Malik al-dar is majhul or Majhul al-Hal] in 1395 AH on his work on Tawassul, however two years before his death in his editing of al-Targhib wal Tarhib, he graded a narration with Malik al-dar as Hasan [good] and mentioned Ibn Hibban authentication of him
📚 Targhib wa al-Tarhib 1/398-399, 1326
So you see him authenticating and weakening [narrations] according to his school of thought (bias), and for this reason, contradictions abound from him and he abandons the established rules
3) Muhammad ibn Maymun, a narrator whome only Imam Ibn Hibban authenticated, as he mentioned him in his Kitab al-Thiqat, and has no Jarah (Criticism). However Imam Ali Ibn Madini explicitly declared Majhul (Unknown)
Now Look at his Narration of Sunan Abu Dawud and how Scholars Even Albani graded it as Sahih [Authentic] / Hasan[Good]
Note- This Narration has no other chain of narration which can bypass Muhammad ibn Maymun, hence it cannot be said that, its authentic due to supporting narrations
📚 Sunan Abu Dawud 3628
• Albani : Hasan
• Shuayb al-ArnautArnaut : Hasan
• Hafiz Zubayr Ali Zai : Hasan
• Imam Ibn Hajar : Hasan
• Imam Hakim : Sahih
• Imam Dhahabi : Sahih
Imam Hibban was lenient, whose authentication has no weight. Right?
So what just happened here?
This is just one case, I can show you too many even worse than this where narrators has not even been authenticated by Imam ibn Hibban yet Objectors graded their solitary narration as Hasan, but I don't want to strech this section anymore unnecessary. For geniune seeker of Knowledge this is more than enough
Now Let's see investigation of Malik al-dar and see how Imam Ibn Hibban was not lenient on him and his Authentication is Valid and acceptable
Investigation of Malik al-Dar
Malik al- dar was :
• Well known Senior Tabi
• Muhaddis [Hadith Scholar]
• Faqih [Jurist]
• Muttafaq alayh Tabi [Agreed Upon Tabi : Upright/Reliable]
• Athna alayhi al-tabiun [Tabin Praised him : Tadil]
• Has No Criticism [Jarah]
• Narrated from Abu Bakr, Umar, Muadh, and Abu Ubayda
• Abu Salih al-Samman narrated from him
• Freed Slave of Umar Ibn al-Khattab
• Trustworthy of Umar Ibn al-Khattab : Treasurer
• Trustworthy of Uthman Ibn Affan : Incharge of the Distribution
• Had Idrak [Born during the life of Rasoolallah]
The above mentioned result of Investigation is based on the following -
1) Imam Ibn Sa'd [d. 230 AH] :
• First layer of Successors [ Senior Tabi’in] among people of Madina
• Freed slave of Umar ibn al-Khattab
• He narrated on the authority of Abu Bakr and Umar
• Abu Salih al-Samman narrated on his authority
• He was well-known
📚 Kitab al-Tabaqat 7/12, 1423
2) Imam Khalifa ibn Khayyat [Teacher of Imam Bukhari] [d. 240 AH] :
• First level of successors [Tabi’in] in Madina to be recognised as Hadith scholars [Muhaddith] and Jurist [Fuqih]
📚 Tabaqat al-Khaifa Ibn Khayyat 1/411, 2010
3) Al-Qadi Abdullah al-Muqaddami [d. 301 AH] :
• Muhaddith, the treasurer of Umar
📚 al-Tarikh wa asma al-Muhaddithin 1/81, 337
4) Imam Abu Yala al-Khalili [d. 446 AH] :
• Malik al-Dar, the freed slave of Umar ibn al-Khattab
• An early Tabi'in, agreed upon [Muttafaq `alayh]
• The Tabi'n praised him [Athna `alayhi al-tabi`un]
📚 al-Irshad 1/313
Note - "An early Tabi'in, agreed upon [Muttafaq alayh]" means that, he was Upright and Reliable in Hadith as mentioned by Imam Ibn Hajar
Imam Ibn Hajar : commented on the same phrase "Muttafaq alayh" by Imam Abu Yala on a narrator, Abbas ibn Muhammad al-Duri and said :
• Muttafaq Alaihi - ya'ni ala adalatihi [Agreed upon, meaning agreement concerning his uprightness and integrity] otherwise neither of the two sheikhs [Imam Bukhari and Muslim] included anything from him
📚 Tahdhib al-Tahdhib 2/294
The term Muttafaq ʿAlayhi is generally associated with a hadith agreed upon by Imam al-Bukhari and Imam Muslim. However, Imam al-Khalili used this term to describe narrators.
As clarified by Amir al-Mu’minin fi al-Hadith, Shaykh al-Islam Imam Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani, the expression means “agreement concerning his uprightness” (ya‘ni ‘ala ‘adalatihi). This explanation establishes the significance of al-Khalili’s terminology in al-Jarh wa al-Ta‘dil, indicating that the expression concerns agreement regarding a narrator’s uprightness
And if Objectors interpret it as something else than bring us the proof from Rijal Scholars
5) Imam Ibn Hajar Al-Asqalani [d. 852 AH] :
• Malik ibn Iyad: Umar's freedman
• He is the one named Malik al-Dar
• He had Edrak [Born during the life of Rasoolallah]
• He has narrated from Abu Bakr and Umar, Muadh, and Abu Ubayda
• Abu Salih al-Samman and his two sonsa [Awn and Abdulllah] narrated from him
• Abd al-Rahman ibn Said ibn Yarbu al-Makhzumi also narrated from him
• Abu Ubayda said of him :
Umar put him in charge of the dependents in his household, When Uthman succeeded him, he put him in charge of financial allotmentsand he was then named Malik of the House [al-dar]
📚 al-Isaba fi-Tamyiz al-Sahaba 6/216, 8375
• Mentioned the Statement of Umar Ibn al-Khattab mentioned in the narration of Musannaf Ibn Abi Shaybah along with the same chain of Transmission without any criticism of Malik al-dar or anyone on the chain
📚 Tarikh al-kabir 4/304-305, 1295
• Mentioned the Authentication of Malik al-dar by Imam Ibn Hibban without any Criticism
📚 Tahdhib al-Tahdhib 3/361
Malik al-Dar is not majhul, nor is his status based solely on Ibn Hibban’s Authentication, but also on the statements of Ibn Sa’d, al-Khalili and Ibn Hajar. Furthermore, Three recognized hadith scholars classified him as a Sahabi, presumably relying on earlier sources. The fact that these sources are unknown to us does not justify dismissing their assessments. Although other scholars classified him as a Tabi‘i, this demonstrates a difference of opinion over whether he was a Sahabi or a Tabi‘i.
Also what is worth noting is the fact that He has no Jarah
Principles Of Al-Jarh wa l-Ta'dil [Criticism And Praise] And Malik al-Dar
Al-Jarh wa l-Ta'dil literally means "disparagement (criticism) and validation (praise)" of narrators. It is the Islamic science used to vet the credibility of Hadith transmitters to separate Authentic narrations from weak or fabricated ones
In the above sections, we have already established the authentication of Malik al-Dar. Hence, this section is included just for the benefit of the seeker of knowledge regarding Majhul al-Hal narrators and how scholars of Rijal treated them, proving that even if Malik al-Dar is Majhul al-Hal, his narration is still acceptable
1) Imam Abu Hatim :
• In Al-Jarh wa al-Ta'dil, Imam Ibn Abi Hatim includes a chapter stating that the narration of a trustworthy narrator from an unknown narrator benefits him. His father, Imam Abu Hatim al-Razi, explicitly states: “If he is unknown, the narration of a trustworthy narrator from him benefits him.”
Note - Two Trustworthy narrators [1. Abu Salih al-Samman and 2. Abd al-Rahman ibn Said ibn Yarbu al-Makhzumi] narrated from Malik al-dar and Malik has no jarah hence the Two Trustworthy narrators benefits him
📚 Al-Jarh wa al-Ta'dil, 1/36
2) Imam al-Daraqutni :
• Whoever has two trustworthy narrators narrating from him, his anonymity is removed and his uprightness (adalah) is established
Note - As mentioned before Two Trustworthy narrators [1. Abu Salih al-Samman and 2. Abd al-Rahman ibn Said ibn Yarbu al-Makhzumi] narrated from Malik al-dar, Hence his anonymity is removed and his uprightness (adalah) is established
📚 Fath al-Mughith 2/54
2) Imam Dhahabi :
• He explains that, Reports of unknown narrators from the senior or middle generation of the Tabiun are accepted and received with a favorable presumption, provided they do not contradict established principles or contain awkward wordings
Note - Malik al dar is a Senior Tabi hence his narrations are accepted and received with a favorable presumption
Imam Dhahabi himself graded narrations from Majhul ul hal senior Tabi as Sahih [Authentic], for example, Narration of Dawud ibn Abi Salih al-Hijazi from 3rd Generation, Middle Tabiun [Hakim 8571]
📚 Diwan al-Du'afa 1/478
He commented on a narrator, Rabi ibn Ziyad al-Hamdani [Only Imam Ibn Hibban Deemed him Authentic, Thiqa] and Said :
• I have not seen anyone declare him weak, and his narration are acceptable
Note - No one declared Malik al-Dar weak, hence his narration are also acceptable
📚 Mizan al-Itidal 2/40, 2736
4) Imam Ibn Rajab
• Ibn Rajab’s explains Imam al-Shafi‘i’s position with approval that, even a mursal hadith may be accepted if certain conditions are met:
1. The narrator is not known to narrate from unacceptable narrators
2. He does not contradict reliable hadith scholars when transmitting the report with a connected chain
3. He is among the senior Tabi‘in, who generally narrate from Companions or senior Tabi‘in.
Note - In the case narration of Musannaf Ibn Abi Shaybah, Abu Salih al-Samman who was a trustworthy narrator and senior Tabi and was not known to narrate from unacceptable narrators, and he narrated from Malik al-Dar, a senior Tabi‘i. This provides a relevant point of comparison with Imam al-Shafi‘i’s conditions for accepting even mursal narrations where intermediate is not named yet its acceptable
📚 Sharh Ilal al-Tirmidhi 1/188
Objection 4️⃣ : Inqita [Disconnecton] : Abu Salih didn't hear from Malik al-dar
Response —
Another baseless and Stupid Objection
The claim that Abu Salih did not hear from Malik al-Dar lacks established evidence
The classical biographical authorities themselves explicitly mention Abu Salih al-Samman among those who narrated from Malik al-Dar. For example, Ibn Saʿd, Ibn Hibban and Ibn Hajar [See section 6 Investigation of Malik al-dar]. And these is something which many Rjal scholars mentioned apart from the scholars mentioned above
The use of the expression ʿan [On the Authority] does not establish disconnection. If the objector argues that Abu Salih used the expression ʿan rather than explicitly stating samiʿtu [Heard], this objection is insufficient Because Abu Salih al-Samman is an established trustworthy narrator and he is not established as a Mudallis [narrator known for practising tadlis]
The possibility of meeting between Abu Salih al-Samman and Malik al-Dar is established by their shared geographical association with Medina and their historical contemporaneity
Abu Salih was a senior Successor from Medina and, Imam al-Dhahabi describes him as one of the senior scholars of that city. Al-Dhahabi further mentions that Abu Salih was born during the caliphate of Umar, witnessed the siege of Uthman in 35 AH, and died in 101 AH
📚 Siyar Alam al-Nubala 5/36-37
Note -Malik al-Dar was also associated with Medina and served during the caliphates of Umar and Uthman. Thus, their shared city and overlapping lifetimes establish the historical possibility of their meeting and direct hearing
Imam Muslim :
• Whenever a trustworthy man narrates a hadith from another trustworthy man, and it is possible for him to have met him and heard from him because both of them lived in same era, then narration is established and it is binding to use it as evidence, even if there is No report establishing that two of them actually met or spoke to one another...As long as circumstances b/w them remain within possibility we explained, Narration is always treated as one based upon hearing, until there is evidence establishing otherwise
📚 Sahih Muslim
Note - Malik al-dar and Abu Salih contemporaneity and the possibility of meeting are established. They both associated with Madinah. Their historical periods overlap, and there is no established chronological obstacle to their meeting. Therefore, the conditions described by Imām Muslim are applicable to this transmission
Also There is specific classical evidence suggesting actual hearing
Imam Abu Yala al-Khalili [d. 446 AH] :
• It is said that Abu Salih heard this particular hadith from Malik al-Dar
📚 al-Irshad 1/316
Objection 5️⃣ : Al-A'mash is a Mudallis
Al-A'mash is a mudallis [one who practices tadlis], sometimes omits a narrator in b/w when reporting with wording "an" [from] rather than "haddathana" [I heard]. In this chain, he said "an Abu Salih", so he is doing tadlis
Imam Bayhaqi, Hakim, and Sufyan al-Thawri, Dhahabi...said regarding a narration : Al-Amash didn't hear this from Abu Salih
Hence, the narration is weak
Response —
This claim is partly true, as al-A'mash did practice tadlis sometimes
However, not every narration of his reported with wording "an" [from] is weak and has tadlis. Hence, the claim is only partially correct, Which doesn't affect authenticity of this chain
Let me give you reasons, Why "an" [from] of al-Amash from Abu Salih is not affecting the authenticity of the chain and i wil also explain why the scholars said what the objectors presented in thier defence
1) Imam Ibn Hajar
• al-A'mash practiced tadlis and was described as a mudallis by several hadith critics. However, he places him in 2nd category of Mudallis - reliable imams whose tadlis were tolerated due to their trustworthiness & relative rarity of their tadlis
📚 Tabaqat al-Mudallisin 1/23,67
He also said :
• Abu Mu'awiyah → [From] al-A'mash → [From] Abu Salih
• This chain occurs frequently, and it is one of the most authentic chains of transmission
📚 Huda al-Sari 1/260
2) Imam Dhahabi :
• When he [al-A'mash] said, "He narrated to us," there is no issue. But whenever he said "from," possibility of tadlis arises, except with his teachers, such as Ibrahim, Ibn Abi Wa'il, & Abu Salih. For his narrations from this category are considered connected
📚 Mizan al-Itidal 2/224
Even Objectors Shiekh And Muhaddis didn't raise this objection against this narration because he also defended "an" [from] of al-Amash from Abu Salih in a narration citing the above mentioned statement of Imam Dhahabi
3) Albani :
• As for the fact that he [al-Amash] did not mention the person who informed him, this is an apparent defect in the narration, based on the fact that al-A'mash was a Mudallis and did not explicitly state that he heard it. However, the scholars have proceeded on accepting the narrations of al-A'mash transmitted with 'an'anah, unless a break in the chain becomes evident. Al-Dhahabi said in his biography in Al-Mizan...
• The point intended as evidence from his statement is simply that declaring al-A'mash's narration defective merely because of 'an'anah is not an absolute rule. This is the approach followed by the verifying scholars, such as Ibn Hajar and others. Among them was al-Mundhiri himself. How many narrations of al-A'mash transmitted with 'an'anah did al-Mundhiri authenticate, let alone other scholars!
📚 Silsilat al-Hadith as-Sahiha, 5/403-404, 1794
Now as for Imam Bayhaqi, Hakim, Sufyan al-Thawri and Dhahabi...who said regarding a narration : Al-Amash didn't hear this from Abu Salih
They said this because the examination of that specific report establishes the presence of a missing link or a lack of direct hearing hence the defect is only on that specific report and this doesn't harm his other narrations until and unless the examination of other narrations also establishes the presence of a missing link or a lack of direct hearing
al-Humaydi [d. 219 AH] :
• When a narrator is known to have regularly heard from a particular shaykh, his narrations from that shaykh are presumed to be connected. Mere possibility of an omitted intermediary is not sufficient to render a report disconnected, Rather, the narration remains accepted unless an examination of that specific report establishes evidence of a missing link or a lack of direct hearing
📚 al-Kifayah fi Marifat Usul Ilm ar-Riwayah 1/409, 1190
Abu Khalid al-Ahmar :
• I heard al-A'mash say: ‘I heard one thousand [1000] hadiths from Abu Salih
📚 Kitab al-Illal wa-Marifat al-Rijal 2/433, 2910
This is exactly what Albani said as mentioned earlier :
• "...However, the scholars have proceeded on accepting the narrations of al-A'mash transmitted with 'an'anah, unless a break in the chain becomes evident..."
For example -
Rasoolallah said : "The Imam is a guarantor and the Mu'adhdhin is entrusted. O Allah, guide the Imams and forgive the Mu'adhdhins." In the narration of Abu Hamza, it is stated that a man said: "O Messenger of Allah! You neglected us while we were eager for the Adhan after you."
📚 Sunan al-Kubra Bayhaqi 2022
In this chain of narration al-Amash is narrating on the authority ['an'anah] from Abu Salih. So here the by default ruling is that it is connected. However the examination of this narration shows that al-Amash narrated this from an intermediary man [unknown] who narrated it from Abu Salih. Hence the by default ruling of narration being connected is overridden and its now disconnected
This is why Imam Bayhaqi said :
• al-A'mash certainly did not hear this hadith directly from Abu Salih. Rather, he heard it from a man, who narrated it from Abu Salih
[See the chain of transmission of narration 2023, here al-Amash is narrating this same narration from an unknown man who is narrating from Abu Salih]
📚 Sunan al-Kubra Bayhaqi 1/632, 2022
And on this particular narration other scholars like Imam Dhahabi and Sufyan al-Thawri commented that al-Amash didn't heard this from Abu Salih
Hence Only this narration will be deemed disconnected not others. For others the by default ruling is that it is connected unless the examination of other narrations establishes the presence of a missing link or a lack of direct hearing
So we ask the Objectors to do examination of narration of malik al dar and show us the presence of a missing link or a lack of direct hearing of this particular narration
Until and unless its connected
Objection 6️⃣ : Narration of al-A'mash 'an'anah [from] Abu Salih Needs corroboration
Narrations of al-A'mash from Abu Salih with "an" occur frequently. But, those narrations have other chains where sama (direct hearing) is proven or chain have other routes; hence, due to corroboration, his tadlis was tolerated. And narration of Malik al-Dar, has no other chain. So, this chain is weak
Response —
Again, partially true. Yes, there are corroborations due to which narrations get strengthened, however, this particular chain is authentic even without corroboration as we have already proved in the above section
We also have examples from Muhaddithin themselves, where they graded a chain as Sahih or Hasan without corroboration
Here are some narrations that do not have another chain apart from al-A'mash From Abu Salih. Therefore, the claim or usul of corroboration does not apply here
Imam Muslim
📚 Sahih Muslim 81a
Imam Ibn Hibban
📚 Sahih Ibn hibban 2759
Imam Tirmidhi
📚 Jami at-Tirmidhi 3780
Imam Hakim
📚 Al-Mustadrak 1532
Objection 7️⃣ : Imam Ibn Hajar only authenticated the chain up to Abu Salih, not the whole chain
Response —
This is literally just how they cope, and nothing else
Albani came up with this absurd objection in his work Tawassul for the first time
Ibn Hajar attributes the narration to Abu Salih transmitting from Malik al-Dar and describes its chain as authentic.
He said :
• Ibn Abi Shaybah narrated, with an authentic chain of transmission, through the narration of Abu Salih al-Samman from Malik al-Dar...
📚 Fath al-Bari 4/115
1. Its chain is authentic only up to Abu Salih
2. Its chain is authentic except for Malik al-Dar
3. Malik al-Dar is unknown or unreliable
Ibn Hajar's wording regarding the report of Malik al-Dar is materially different from his wording in cases where he intends to limit authentication to a specific narrator
For example -
In al-Talkhis al-Habir, he explicitly says: "إسناده صحيح إلى سعيد بن جبير" [Its chain of transmission is authentic up to Sa'id bin Jubayr.] and then immediately clarifies the defect beyond that point : "إلا أن سعيدًا لم يدرك ركانة" [except that Sa'id did not meet Rukanah.]
This is a clear example of a restricted authentication
📚 al-Talkhis al-Habir, 4/299, 2484
By contrast, regarding the Malik al-Dar narration, Ibn Hajar says: "بإسناد صحيح من رواية أبي صالح السمان عن مالك الدار". He does not say "إلى أبي صالح" [Upto Abu Salih] nor does he mention any interruption, weakness, or defect after Abu Salih. According to standard hadith terminology, when a scholar intends to authenticate only up to a certain narrator, he normally states that limitation explicitly. Since Ibn Hajar did not do so here, the apparent meaning of his statement is that the isnad he cited is Sahih, not merely Sahih up to Abu Salih
Objection 8️⃣ : Isnad [Chain] is Authentic but Matan [Text] is Daef [Weak]
The chain of transmission [isnad] is sahih, but the hadith is weak because of the Matan, as it goes against, Sahih al-Bukhari (1010), where Umar did not go to the grave of Rasool Allah ﷺ for rain; rather, he asked al-Abbas to invoke Allah for it
Response —
Again, this is an absurd and flawed argument. Both hadiths are sahih, and they do not contradict each other.
In the narration of Malik al-Dar, it was not Umar who went to the grave; rather, it was someone else.
Furthermore, the actions of different people may differ. If Umar did not do something, that does not automatically make that action bid'ah, Haram or shirk.
There is no report-not even a weak one-stating that Umar sought blessings through the hair of Rasool Allah. However, other companions of Rasool Allah did so.
So now what?
Would that become bid'ah, Haram or shirk simply because Umar did not do it, or because none of the Khulafa' al-Rashidun did it as well?
What kind of usul is this, exactly?
Moreover, you and I are nothing in comparison to the classical scholars. So tell me: which classical scholar has ever said that its matn is weak and that it contradicts the actions of the companions of Rasool Allah and the Qur'an?
On the contrary, they authenticated the narration without mentioning a single word of criticism, as they do with narrations they consider weak.
Had it been shirk, they would not merely have refrained from authenticating it; they would have explicitly clarified its defect. Yet they did not write a single line against it.
Scholars's Authentication
Now, here are some classical scholars of Ahlus Sunnah wa al-Jamaah who authenticated, or considered the narration of Malik al-Dar as Sahih [authentic] —
1. Imam al-Bayhaqi [d. 458 AH]
• And know that every hadith I have included in it I have accompanied with what indicates its authenticity, or I have left it unsaid, and it is acceptable in what I have included
📚 Dalail al-Nubuwwah 7/47
2. Imam Ibn Kathir [d. 774 AH]
• This is a sound [Sahih] chain of narration
📚 Al-Bidayah wa'l-Nihayah 7/205
3. Imam Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani [d. 852 AH]
• Ibn Abi Shaybah narrated, with an authentic [Sahih] chain of transmission
📚 Fath al-Bari 4/115
4. Imam al-Samhudi [d. 911 AH]
• Ibn Abi Shaybah narrated, with an authentic [Sahih] chain of transmission
📚 al-Wafa al Wafa bi akhbar Dar al-Mustafa 5/69
5. Imam al-Qastallani [d. 923 AH]
6. Imam al-Zurqani [d. 1122 AH]
• Ibn Abi Shaybah narrated, with an authentic [Sahih] chain of transmission
📚 Sharh al-Mawahib al-Laduniyya 11/150
7. Imam Ibn Hajar al-Haytami [d. 974 AH]
• It is authentically [Sahih] reported
📚 al-Jawhar al-Munazzam p.112
8. Shaykh Dawud ibn Sulayman al-Baghdadi al-Khalidi (d.1299 AH/1881 CE)
• al-Bayhaqi and Abu Shaybah with a sound [Sahih] chain of transmission
📚 al-Minhatul Wahbiyya 1/97
• Reported by al-Bayhaqi and Ibn Abi Shaybah in a lengthy hadith with an authentic [Sahih] chain of narration.”
📚 Nusra al Imam al Subki bi-radd al Sarim al Munki 1/115
10. Sheikh Mahmud Sa’id Mamduh (student of Sheikh al-Ghumari)
• The conclusion of what has been mentioned is that the report of Malik al-Dar concerning coming to the Noble Grave is authentic [Sahih]
📚 Raf al-Minara 1/235-255
11. Shaykh Jamil Effendi al-Zahawi (1355 AH/d. 1936 CE)
• Narrated by al-Bayhaqi and Ibn Abi Shaybah with an authentic [Sahih] chain of transmission
📚 al-Fajr al-sadiq fi al-radd `ala munkiri al-tawassul 1/47
Even Sheikh Islam of Objectors acknowledged it without any criticism
Ibn Taymiyyah [d. 728 AH]
• And the like of that. All of this is true
• And the like of this occurs frequently for those who are below the Prophet, and I know of incidents of this kind
📚 Iqtida al-Sirat al-Mustaqim 2/254

























