Narration of Uthman Ibn Hunayf
Dua of Waseela, after the passing of RasoolAllah ﷺ which he taught to a Tab'i for his needs to get fullfiled :
❝O Allah, I ask You and turn to You through Your Prophet Muhammad, O Muhammad, I turn with you to my Lord, so that He may fulfill my need❞
> Complete Narration :
A man used to go to Uthman ibn Affan regarding a need of his, but Uthman would not pay attention to him nor look into his matter. The man met Uthman ibn Hunayf and complained about this to him.
Uthman ibn Hunayf said to him :
"Go to the place of ablution, perform wudu, then go to the mosque and pray two rak'ahs. Then say: 'O Allah, I ask You and turn to You through our Prophet Muhammad, the Prophet of Mercy. O Muhammad, I turn through you to your Lord-my Lord, the Mighty and Majestic-that He may fulfill my need.' Then mention your need, and afterwards come to me so that I may go with you."
The man went and did exactly as Uthmän instructed him. Then he came to the door of Uthman (ibn Affan). The doorkeeper came, took him by the hand, and admitted him to Uthman ibn Affan. Uthman seated him beside him on the cushion and said:
"What is your need?"
The man mentioned his need, and 'Uthman fulfilled it for him. Then he said:
"You had not mentioned your need until this very moment. Whatever need you have in the future, come to us."
The man then left and met 'Uthman ibn Hunayf.
He said: "May Allah reward you with goodness! He would neither pay attention to my need nor look into it until you spoke to him on my behalf."
Uthman ibn Hunayf replied :
"By Allah, I did not speak to him. Rather, I witnessed the Messenger of Allah, when a blind man came to him and complained to him about the loss of his eyesight. The Prophet said to him:
Will you be patient?
He replied:
O Messenger of Allah, I have no one to lead me, and it has become difficult for me.'
The Prophet then said:
'Go to the place of ablution, perform wudü', then pray two rak'ahs, and then supplicate with these words. [Dua of Waseela]
Uthman ibn Hunayf said:
"By Allah, we had not yet dispersed, and our conversation had not become lengthy, when the man came back to us as though he had never suffered any impairment at all."
📚 Ma'jam As Sagheer, Volume 1, Page 306-307, Hadith number 508
> Note :
First thing which you should know is that this narration of Imam al-Tabarani has two parts:
1) Historical Athar [Story] - Incident/actions/words of Companion
2) Prophetic Hadith - Statement of the Prophet , transmitted by the Companion
Many hadith books contain the Hadith part with different chains of transmission and have been graded authentic, but they do not mention the historical Athar [Story] reported by Imam al-Tabarani
Therefore, the objectors question the authenticity of the historical Athar
The Objectors consider this unauthentic simply because it goes against their flawed Aqeedah that one cannot supplicate with these words of Waseela [The dua taught by RasoolAllah ﷺ] after his passing
However, this dua of Waseela was taught by the Companion himself after the passing of RasoolAllah ﷺ, who had learned it directly, when Rasul Allah ﷺ was present among them
And this historical Athar [narration] is authentic
> Chain of Narration [Isnad] :
→ Tahir ibn Isa ibn Qayrs al-Misri al-Tamimi
→ Asbagh ibn al-Faraj
→ Abdullah ibn Wahb
→ Shabib ibn Sa'id al-Makki
→ Ruh ibn al-Qasim
→ Abu Ja'far al-Khatmi al-Madani
→ Abu Umamah ibn Sahl ibn Hunayf
Let's Begin
Objection 1️⃣ : Tahir ibn Isa ibn Qayrs al-Misri al-Tamimi, is Unknown [Majhul]
Response —
• Ibn Makula :
Tahir ibn Isa ibn Ishaq ibn Abdullah ibn Aban ibn Abd al-Samad ibn Bashir, a client of Banu Tamim, known as Ibn Firas, narrated from...He was a scribe in the army of Egypt and was Trustworthy. He died in the year 292 AH
Objection 2️⃣ : Shabib ibn Sa'id had weak memory and must fulfill two conditions
Shabib ibn Sa'id is the sole narrator of this story [Historical athar], including the hadith portion, and he had a weak memory
His narrations are considered authentic only under two conditions:
1. He Must narrates from Yunus
2. His son Ahmad Must narrates from him
Response —
The first person in Islamic history to impose these conditions on Shabib was none other than al-Albani, in an attempt to weaken this narration, followed by those who blindly followed him
Before explaining the flawed understanding that led him [al-Albani] to derive these conditions from the statements of some scholars, let's first see what other scholars have said about Shabib
• Ibn al-Madini :
Trustworthy. He used to travel to Egypt for trade, and his book is a sound book
• Abu Zurah :
There is no harm in him
• Al-Nasai :
There is no harm in him
• Ibn Hibban :
Mentioned him in al-Thiqat [Trustworthy]
• Al-Daraqutni :
Trustworthy
• Ibn Khalafun
• Al-Dhuhli
Ibn Khalafun transmitted al-Dhuhli's declaration that he was trustworthy
• Al-Tabarani :
Trustworthy
📚 Tahdhib al-Tahdhib 3/135
Did you see any conditions here? Or any criticism?
Now the question is
How did al-Albani come up with the above-mentioned conditions and claim of weak memory?
Answer — He misunderstood some scholars
Let's see, what those scholars said, upon whom he relied for these conditions
[I have explained in detail in bold note, why al-Albani's conclusion regarding Shabib from these statements of scholars, along with the conditions he imposed, is flawed and unfounded]
1) Abu Hatim:
"He had the books of Yunus ibn Yazid, and he is Salih [Reliable/good] al-Hadith; there is no harm in him"
Note : Here, Abu Hatim merely stated that Shabib possessed the books of Yunus and also declared Shabib to be an authentic hadith narrator. However, nowhere did he say that only the narrations from Yunus's collection are authentic, nor did he make any mention of Ahmad or Memory of Shabib.
📚 Tahdhib al-Tahdhib 3/135
2) Ibn Adi:
"Shabib had al-Zuhri collection from Yunus from al-Zuhri with him, and they are sound narrations"
Note: Here, Ibn Adi mentioned that Shabib possessed the books of Yunus from al-Zuhri, which contain sound narrations. However, nowhere did he say that only those books are sound and that the rest of Shabib's narrations are weak.
"Ibn Wahb narrated objectionable narrations from him"
"Whenever his son Ahmad ibn Shabib narrated from him the collection of Yunus from al-Zuhri, they are sound narrations"
"He is not the Shabib from whom Ibn Wahb narrates the objectionable narrations that he [Ahmad] narrates from him [Shabib]"
"Perhaps when Shabib was in Egypt for his trade there, Ibn Wahb wrote from him from his memory, so he made mistakes and erred. And I hope that this Shabib did not deliberately lie"
Note: After finding objectionable narrations through Ibn Wahb's route, Ibn Adi proposed a possible explanation, saying: 'Perhaps (لعل) Ibn Wahb heard or wrote from Shabib while he was narrating from memory during his trip to Egypt, and therefore mistakes occurred.' However, he was not certain. This does not, by itself, establish that Ibn Adi considered Shabib generally weak in memory, nor that every narration from memory was weak
Furthermore, Ibn Adi does not state that he found objectionable narrations in every report transmitted by Shabib outside the Yunus manuscript. Rather, the objection that prompted his explanation concerns the specific route of Ibn Wahb. Consequently, his statement cannot, by itself, be extended into a general principle that all of
Shabib's non-Yunus narrations are weak or that every narration transmitted from his memory is unreliable.
And even if we take his explanation seriously and into consideration, then for better scrutiny of Shabib's narrations, we can derive only one condition: that the narrations transmitted by Ahmad [his son] are authentic or reliable.
As for his statement that whenever his son Ahmad narrates the collection of Yunus from al-Zuhri, the narrations are sound, he is merely mentioning a chain of transmission that is unquestionably authentic. However He did not explicitly present this as the only condition for the authenticity of Shabib's narrations as he was not a weak narrator
📚 Al-Kamil fi al-Du'afa 5/47-49
3) Imam al-Dhahabi :
"Ibn Adi said: Perhaps Shabib would make mistakes and err when he narrated from memory, and I hope that he did not do so deliberately. So when his son Ahmad narrated from him the hadiths of Yunus, it was as if he were a different Shabib-meaning he was more accurate"
Note: The above is al-Dhahabi's abridged citation of Ibn Adi's statement in al-Kamil, not his complete wording. When read in isolation, it may give the impression that Ibn Adi regarded Shabib as generally weak in memory or that he would err whenever he narrated from memory. However, this is not the impression conveyed by Ibn Adi's original discussion. Upon consulting the complete passage, it becomes clear that Ibn Adi was addressing a specific circumstance concerning the objectionable narrations transmitted through Ibn Wahb and then offered a tentative explanation ) لعل ( for that particular case during Shabib's journey to Egypt
And al-Dhahabi himself graded Shabib as Saduq, yughrib: Truthful, he narrates uncommon (or unusual) reports. Not Saduq, yukhti: Truthful but makes mistakes
📚 Mizan al-Itidal 3/362
Here, it becomes clear that
- When Ahmad ibn Shabib narrates from his father [Shabib] → The narrations are authentic
- However, when Ibn Wahb narrates from him [Shabib] → The narrations are objectionable
This is exactly what Imam Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani said :
"There is nothing wrong with his hadiths narrated by his son Ahmad from him, not by Ibn Wahb"
Bashar Awad Maarouf & Sheikh Shuaib Al-Arnaout commented :
"Rather: Trustworthy except in the narration of Ibn Wahb from him"
📚 Tahrir Taqrib al-Tahdhib 2739, 2/105
Al-Albani disagreed with Ibn Hajar's statement of Taqrib and said:
"This is deficient, since it gives the impression that all narrations of his son Ahmad from him are acceptable"
He then cited another statement of Ibn Hajar from Hady al-Sari and used it in his defence
Here, Imam Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani said :
"Al-Bukhari included hadiths narrated by his son on the authority of Yunus, but he did not include anything narrated by him on the authority of anyone other than Yunus, nor anything narrated by Ibn Wahb on his authority"
• Sheikh Mehmood Saeed replied :
Bukhari sought only the most authentic narrations. Since Yunus was among foremost students of al-Zuhri, and Shabib had copy of Yunus from al-Zuhri he included Shabib narrations only through
Ahmad → Shabib → Yunus
which met the strict criterion of his Sahih
This does not mean, Shabib's other routes are weak, as Bukhari did not intend to include every authentic narrations
Ibn Hajar states that a narration's absence from the Sahih Bukhari does not make it unsuitable as evidence. Rather, they simply did not meet Bukhari strict criterion of his Sahih
Moreover, no scholar before al-Albani is known to have rejected Shabib's narrations based on these two conditions
[This is a summary. Read full Statement from the Image]
📚 Rafal-Manarah 1/116-117
And Imam Ibn Hajar mentioned only one condition in Taqrib not two. Since Taqrib is concise summary of a narrator's status, had both been intended as general conditions, he would have mentioned both
This clearly shows the two conditions were specific to Bukhari [Most Authentic]
al-Albani treated Shabib as though he belonged to the category of weak narrators whose reports are accepted only under specific conditions, despite the earlier Scholars generally classifying him among the trustworthy narrators
Even if criticism of Shabib's non-Yunus narrations is "Assumed", it remains unexplained [Jarh ghayr mufassar]. By contrast, Ibn Adi provides a specific explanation only for Ibn Wahb's transmission
Therefore, only the explained criticism can qualify the established tadil [Praise]
Imam Ibn Hajar Al-'Asqalani, explains that jarh is only preferred over tadil when it is explained and issued by a qualified critic. Otherwise, it is not accepted against an established trustworthy narrator
📚 Sharh Nukhbat al-Fikar fi Mustalah Ahl al-Athar 1/136
The Conclusion :
Shabib ibn Sa'id is trustworthy except for what was narrated from him by Ibn Wahb. Though, not all of those narrations can be deemed objectionable with certainty
However, as for precaution, bare minimum condition is
Any trustworthy narrator → Shabib → Ahmad
Objection 3️⃣ : The bare minimum condition is not fulfilled [Ahmad didn't narrate]
Even the bare minimum condition is not fulfilled in al-Tabarani's narration, since it is Ibn Wahb [not Ahmad] who narrates from Shabib
Response —
Yes, that is true. However, we have another chain of Transmission for this narration in which Ahmad [the son of Shabib] narrates from Shabib [his father], not Ibn Wahb from Shabib
Chain of transmission [Isnad]:
→ Abdullah ibn Jafar
→ Yaqub ibn Sufyan al-Fasawi
→ Ahmad ibn Shabib ibn Said
→ his father [Shabib ibn Said]
→ Ruh ibn al-Qasim
→ Abu Jafar al-Madani
→ Abu Umamah ibn Sahl ibn Hunayf
→ His uncle [Uthman ibn Hunayf]
📚 Mashyakhat, Yaqub ibn Sufyan al-Fasawi, Hadith 113
We have another chain of Transmission in which Ismail [the other son of Shabib] narrates from Shabib [his father], not Ibn Wahb from Shabib
Chain of transmission [Isnad] :
→ Abu Said Abd al-Malik ibn Abi Uthman al-Zahid
→ Imam Abu Bakr Muhammad ibn Ali ibn Ismail al-Shashi al-Qaffal
→ Abu Arubah
→ al-Abbas ibn al-Faraj
→ Ismail ibn Shabib
→ his father [Shabib ibn Said]
→ Ruh ibn al-Qasim
→ Abu Jafar al-Madani
→ Abu Umamah ibn Sahl ibn Hunayf
→ His uncle [Uthman ibn Hunayf]
📚 Dalail An nubuwwah 6/167-168
Ibn Wahb was not alone in narrating this report from Shabib. It was also narrated by Ahmad and Ismail, Shabib's two sons, in Basra, providing strong corroboration for Ibn Wahb's narration
Although Ibn Wahb heard it while Shabib was travelling for trade-a situation more prone to memory lapses, his narration completely agrees with the Basran narrations
This significantly weakens the claim that Shabib's narrations from memory are unreliable, as his travel-time narration proved accurate and consistent
Objection 4️⃣ : Other trustworthy narrators didn't narrates this story from Ahmad
Three trustworthy narrators
al-Abbas
al-Husayn ibn Yahya
Muhammad ibn Ali
narrated this hadith from Ahmad ibn Shabib without story, whereas only Yaqub ibn Sufyan al-Fasawi narrated it with story
Therefore, the version without the story should be preferred
Response —
Yaqub ibn Sufyan al-Fasawi was not merely trustworthy; he was an eminent hadith master (Hafiz). According to the principles of hadith criticism, the narration of a distinguished Hafiz is given preference over that of ordinary trustworthy narrators when there is a disagreement
The claim of "three trustworthy narrators against one" is incorrect. Al-Abbas ibn Faraj al-Riyashi actually narrated both versions, including the version containing the story through Ismail ibn Shabib from his father. Therefore, he cannot be counted as opposing Yaqub al-Fasawi
Finally, narrating the hadith with or without the story is not a contradiction. Omitting the story does not invalidate the version that includes it. Since both reports can be reconciled, there is no irreconcilable inconsistency, and the additional story remains acceptable
Objection 5️⃣ : Shabib contradicted trustworthy narrators who didn't mention this story
Shabib ibn Sa'id contradicted the trustworthy narrators by mentioning the Historical story, whereas they narrated the hadith without it. Since his addition opposes the narrations of the trustworthy narrators, it should be rejected
Response —
The narration consists of two distinct parts as we already discussed:
1) Historical Athar : The mawquf historical incident (the Companion's account of a man later acting upon that instruction during the caliphate of Uthman).
2) Prophetic Hadith : The marfu' hadith (the Prophet's instruction to the blind man).
The Prophet's words remain unchanged in all the narrations. The only difference is that Ruh ibn al-Qasim's route, from whom Shabib narrated, also preserves the accompanying historical incident [story], while the other routes simply narrate the marfu' hadith.
[Abu Jafar al-Khatmi transmitted this Hadith through multiple students, including Shu'bah, Hammad ibn Salamah, Ruh ibn al-Qasim, and Hisham al-Dastawa'i. While the other routes preserve only the marfu' hadith, Ruh's route also preserves the accompanying mawquf historical incident.]
This does not amount to a contradiction. A contradiction only exists when one narration negates another. For example, if one narrator says, "The Prophet prayed two rak'ahs," while another says, "The Prophet never prayed two rak'ahs," the two reports cannot both be true. But if one narrator relates the hadith and another relates the same hadith together with an additional historical account, the latter has not contradicted the former; he has merely preserved more information.
I would like to give you an example of an additional wording in narration that was narrated by only one narrator, while the rest did not mention it at all. [Here additional wording is in the prophetic Hadith]
Now read what, Imam ibn Hibban said regarding this:
"Hammad ibn Salamah was the only one who narrated it, and he is trustworthy and reliable. The addition of words is acceptable to us from trustworthy people, as it is possible for a group to attend a sheikh to hear something, then some of it is hidden from one of them, and it is memorized by someone who is like him or less than him in proficiency."
📚 Al-Thiqat 8/1
Hadith scholars accepted the principle that the addition of a trustworthy narrator is accepted so long as it does not conflict with a stronger narration. Since the historical incident neither alters nor contradicts the Prophet's words, there is no basis for rejecting it.
This understanding is further supported by Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal, who stated that when a narration contains a story, it is often an indication that the narrator preserved it more accurately. The inclusion of the historical incident therefore supports careful preservation rather than poor memory.
When al-Albani tried to weaken the story of Uthman ibn Hunayf Sheikh Abdullah ibn Muhammad ibn al-Siddiq al-Ghumari, said:
al-Albani claims that since some narrators whose Hadith are mentioned by Ibn al-Sunni and al-Hakim did not mention the story [about Uthman ibn Hunayf], the story is doubtful (weak). This is another example of al-Albani's trickery. People who have some knowledge about the principles of the science of Hadith know that some narrators report a given Hadith in its entirety, while others may choose to abridge it according to their purpose at hand.
Al-Bukhari, for example, does that routinely in his Sahih where he often mentions a Hadith in abridged form while it is given by someone else in complete form.
Moreover, the person who has related the story [about Uthman ibn Hunayf in al-Bayhaqi's report is an extraordinary Imam: Yaqub ibn Sufyan. Abu Zura al-Dimashqi says about him: "Two men from the noblest of mankind came to us; one of them, Yaqub ibn Sufyan the most widely-traveled of the two, defies the people of Iraq to produce a single man who can narrate [as well] as he does."
Al-Albani's declaring the narration of Awn (hakim 1929), which in fact is weak, to be better than the narration of those who narrated the story [of Uthman ibn Hunayf] is a third aspect of al-Albani's duplicity and fraud because when al-Hakim related the Hadith of the blind man in an abridged form by way of Awn, he remarked: "Shabib ibn Said al-Habati has given the same Hadith by way of Rawh ibn al-Qasim with some additions to the text (matn) and the chain of narrators (isnad). The decision in the matter is Shabib's since he is utterly reliable (thiqa) and trustworthy (mamun)."
What al-Hakim says emphasizes a precept which is universally recognized by the experts in the science of Hadith (al-muhaddithun) and the principles of the holy law (usul al-fiqh); namely, that additional wording related by a narrator who is utterly reliable (thiqa) is acceptable (maqbula), and, furthermore, someone who remembered something is a proof against someone who didn't remember it.
al-Albani saw al-Hakim's statement but he didn't like it, so he ignored it
📚 Ref: Epistle in Refutation of al-Albani, Tawassul & Hadith of the Man in Need
Finally, if Shabib had truly inserted a false historical incident into the narration, the hadith critics would have considered that a serious flaw
and declared him weak. Instead, they continued to regard him as trustworthy, and leading scholars such as al-Tabarani, al-Hakim, and al-Haythami authenticated the narration containing the historical incident.
Objection 6️⃣ : Imam al-Tabarani didn't authenticated the story but hadith
Imam al-Tabarani authenticated only the marfu narration [Prophetic Hadith] and not the mawquf account [Historical Athar: The story of Uthmn ibn Hunayf]
Response —
Imam al-Tabarani declared Shabib ibn Said trustworthy [unconditionally], who narrates the story
Moreover, Imam Haythami & Mundhiri cited al-Tabarani's authentication without raising any objection, indicating no distinction between the marfu narration and the mawquf story
[See scans in next section of scholar's authentication]
Ibn Taymiyyah acknowledged that some of the Salaf used this dua of Waseela
Even Ibn Taymiyyah acknowledged, that some of the Salaf used this dua of Waseela, and the man who recited it was cured
[However he compared tawassul through RasoolAllah ﷺ and being cured with invoking stars, arguing that successful outcome doesn't prove an act's permissibility]
Scholar's Authentication
Now, let's see some scholars who graded this Narration as Authentic or used it as proof of Tawassul through RasoolAllah ﷺ after his passing
> Imam al-Tabarani :
“It was only narrated from Rawh ibn al-Qasim by Shabib ibn Sa'id Abu Sa'id al-Makki, who is trustworthy”
“The Hadith is Authentic”
📚 Ma'jam As Sagheer, 1/306-307, Hadith number 508
“Accepted the authentication of Imam al-Tabarani, without mentioning any critisism”
📚 Majma' al-Zawa'id, 3668, 2/468
> Imam al-Mundhiri :
“Accepted the authentication of Imam al-Tabarani, without mentioning any critisism”
📚 At-Targheeb wa Tarheeb, 1/242
> Imam Muhammad bin Yusuf al-Salihi :
“Chapter 5: Regarding Tawassul through the Prophet AFTER HIS DEATH
It is narrated by al-Tabarani and al-Bayhaqi WITH CONTINEOUS CHAIN HAVING THIQA NARRATORS, the hadith of Uthman ibn Hunayf...”
> Imam al-Bayhaqi :
“And know that every hadith I have included in it I have accompanied with what indicates its authenticity, or I have left it unsaid, and it is acceptable in what I have included”
📚 Dalail An nubuwwah 6/167-168
“Shabib ibn Said, followed him [Awn b. Umarah al-Basari] from Ruh ibn al-Qasim WITH ADDITIONAL WORDINGS IN THE TEXT [MATN] AND CHAIN OF TRANSMISSION. The accepted view regarding it is the view of Shabib, for he is trustworthy and reliable”
📚 Mustadrak 1929
> Shaykh Abdullah al-Ghumari :
This story is authentic (Sahih); Al-Tabarani authenticated it, and Al-Hafiz Al-Mundhiri conveyed his authentication in Al-Targhib, as did Al-Hafiz Al-Haythami in Majma' al-Zawa'id
📚 Ithaf al-Azkiyya bi-Jawaz al-Tawassul bil-Anbiyya wal-Awliyya 1/19
> Sheikh Mehmood Saeed :
“The Conclusion of what has preceded is that, the additional mawquf narration containing the story of man's coming to Uthman ibn Affan is authentic.” Therefore, it was authenticated by leading hadith Scholars, Tabarani, Hakim...”
📚 Rafal-Manarah 1/126
