Narration Of Ayesha
❝During a severe drought in Madinah, People complained to Mother Ayesha, who instructed them to open an opening above the GRAVE of RasoolAllah❞
> Complete Narration
Chapter 15 Chapter : How God Almighty Honored His Prophet After His Death
Abu al-Jawza Aws ibn Abd Allah said: The people of Madinah were afflicted by a severe drought, so they complained to Aishah.
She said: 'Look at the grave of the Prophet and make an opening toward the sky, so that there is no roof between it and the sky.'
They did so, and we were given such abundant rain that the grass grew and the camels became so fat that they nearly burst from their fat. Thus, that year was called the Year of Abundance (Am al-Fatq)."
📚 Musnad al-Darimi [Sunan al-Darimi], 1/227, Hadith 93
> Chain of Narration [Isnad] —
Abu al-Nu'man
[Muhammad ibn al-Fadl/Arim]
↓
Sa'id ibn Zayd
↓
Amr ibn Malik al-Nakri
↓
Abu al-Jawza Aws ibn Abd
Objection 1️⃣ : Arim was Reliable However he suffered deterioration [Memory loss]
Arim was Reliable However he suffered deterioration. Narrations from such narrators are accepted only when it is known that they were heard before deterioration. It is unknown whether Darimi heard this before or after his deterioration
• Ibn Hibban :
Arim deteriorated toward end of his life
Many munkar reports appeared in his narration after deterioration
Narrations heard from him before deterioration are accepted
If it is unknown when narration was heard it shouldn't be used as evidence
📚 Al-Majruhin 2/294
Response —
[Objectuon is not that he was not Trustworthy, but his deterioration. So I will respond only deterioration objection]
The criticism of Imam Hibban has already been refuted by Imam Dhahabi, and Arim's deterioration did not affect what was narrated from him
• Imam Dhahabi :
Al-Daraqutni said: “He changed in his later years, but no Munkar Hadith became apparent from him after becoming confused, and he is trustworthy.”
I said: This is the statement of the Hafiz of his era, after al-Nasai, the likes of whom did not come afterward
So where does this statement stand in comparison to statement of Ibn Hibban, the rash and reckless critic regarding Arim? He said..[Quote]
I said: Ibn Hibban was unable to cite a single Munkar Hadith from him. So where is the evidence for what he claimed?
📚 Mizan al-itida 4/8
• Abu Hatim :
He became confused at the "end of his life" and his intellect deteriorated...I did not hear from him after the confusion...In general, whoever heard from him before the year 220 AH, his hearing is good
..........
He Died in 224 AH
📚 Al-Kawakib 1/386, 393
• Ibn al-Salah :
He became confused in latter part of his life. Therefore, whatever al-Bukhari, Muhammad ibn Yahya al-Dhuhli, and "other major hadith memorisers narrated from him should be considered to have been taken from him before his becoming confused"
📚 Al-Kawakib 1/388
• Al-Iraqi :
And likewise, it is appropriate that the one who narrated from him should be "among the shaykhs of al-Bukhari or Muslim"
📚 Al-Taqyid wa al-Idah p.462
• Alawi al-Maliki :
This does not harm him nor impugn his narration, because al-Bukhari narrated more than 100 hadiths from him in his Sahih, and after his deterioration, no narration was taken from him.
📚 Shifa ul fuad bi ziyarat p.107
• Mehmood Saeed :
I say : al-Darimi was among the teachers of Muslim and al-Bukhari. Therefore, al-Darimi must necessarily be among those who narrated from Muhammad ibn al-Fadl al-Sadusi [Arim] before his detorieation
📚 Rafal-Manarah p.229
Several narrations transmitted by Imam Darimi from Arim are Absolutely authentic. They are narrated in Bukhari and Muslim, or in other books through the same or different chains of transmission, with the same authentic wording
For example
📚 Darimi 2289
📚 Darimi 2250
Therefore, there is no reason to assume that the narration of Aisha regarding the grave of the Prophet was transmitted after Arim’s confusion. Rather, it should also be understood as a narration that Imam Darimi received from him before his confusion
Bonus :
This narration of Imam Tabarani has no other chain which can bypass Arim, and it's a solitary
📚 Mujam al-Kabir 13/290, 14062
• Imam Haythami Graded it HASAN
📚 Majma al-Zawaid 8/559
• Even the editor, al-Darani who graded it DAEF, did so because of another narrator
Objection 2️⃣ : Sa'id ibn Zayd ibn Dirham is Weak [Da'ef] and his Solitary narrations are not Authentic
Response —
Some scholars graded him Weak but there are many who graded him Thiqa [Trustworthy] or Saduq [Truthful], hence Acceptable
Let's see what scholars actually said —
Postive Remarks ✅
1) Imam Ahmad :
• There is no problem with him
2) Imam Muslim :
• Truthful Hafiz
3) Ibn Ma'in :
• Trustworthy
4) Ibn Saad :
• Trustworthy
5) al-Ijli :
• Trustworthy
6) Sulayman Ibn Harb :
• Trustworthy
7) Hibban Ibn Hilal :
Truthful Hafiz
8) Ibn Adi :
He does not have any munkar [Objectionable] narration that is not narrated by anyone other than him [He has no munkar narration for which he is the sole narrator] and in my view, he is among those who are attributed to Truthfulness
📚 Tahdhib al-Tahdhib 2/19
9) Imam Bukhari :
Trustworthy
• At this point we have both Imam Bukhari and Imam Muslim, Authenticating him without any Criticism or conditions
10) Ibn Khalafun :
Trustworthy
📚 Tahdhib al-Kamal 5/295-297
Trustworthy narrators about whom some Imams have spoken in a way that does not invalidate their reports...Their hadiths, if not at the highest level of authenticity, do not fall below the level of good [Hasan]...
📚 Dhikr Asma Man Takallama p. 27, 85
Trustworthy
📚 Ithaf al-Khiyara 8/166
13) Shu'ayb Al-Arna'ut & Dr. Bashar Awad Ma'ruf :
Rather, He is Hasan al-hadith
📚 Taqrib al-Tahdhib 2312
14) Hussein Salim Asad al-Darani :
Trustworthy
📚 Musnad al-Darimi [Sunan al-Darimi], 1/227, Hadith 93
15) Haythami :
Trustworthy
📚 Majma' al-Zawa'id 12/297-298, 9426
16) Muhammad ibn Yusuf al-Salihi al-Shami :
Trustworthy
📚 Subul al-Huda 7/393
Negative Remarks ❌
1) Yahya ibn Said :
Very weak, He is Nothing
2) Abu Hatim :
Not Strong
3) Nasai :
Not Strong
4) al-Juzajani
He is not a proof
5) al-Bazzar :
He is lenient, He did not have good retention
6) Al-Daraqutni :
Weak
7) Ibn Hibban :
He was truthful and a Hafiz, among those who would make mistakes in reports and err, such that he is not to be used as a proof when he narrates alone
📚 Tahdhib al-Tahdhib 2/19
8) Ibn Fakhr :
Same as ibn Hibban
📚 Tahdhib al-Kamal 5/295
9) Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani :
Truthful, but prone to errors
📚 Taqrib al-Tahdhib 2/29, 2312
Analysis —
We find that some scholars declared him weak, while others said he was not strong. These criticisms are ghayr mufassar [unexplained] because they do not specify the reason for the weakness, and therefore do not take precedence over the established ta'dil [Praise]
• Imam Ibn Hajar Al-'Asqalani, explains that jarh is only preferred over tadil when it is explained and issued by a qualified critic. Otherwise, it is not accepted against an established trustworthy narrator
📚 Sharh Nukhbat al-Fikar fi Mustalah Ahl al-Athar 1/136
As for Ibn Hibban, he himself graded him as Truthful hafiz, while mentioning his tendency toward mistakes. His conclusion that his solitary reports should not be relied upon is his methodological judgment, not a universal ruling that must be accepted by every hadith critic
• Abd al-Hakim Salih refuted Ibn Hibban's ruling with Ibn Adi statement
He said :
[He is] Hasan al-Hadith...As for Ibn Hibban’s statement....Ibn Adi examined him and said, “He does not have any munkar narration that no one other than him narrates.”
📚 Taqrib al-Tahdhib 2312
• Likewise, Ibn Hajar didn't grade him weak, but described him as prone to some mistakes. However he also said He is disputed over, but the prevailing position is to regard him as Trustworthy by giving him the symbol [هـ]
📚 Lisan al-Mizan 9/310
• Albani commented on a chain :
Its narrators are all trustworthy. Regarding Sa'id ibn Zayd..there is some criticism of him, but it does not lower his hadith below the rank of Hasan
📚 Irwa al-Alil 5/338
However he deemed him Weak in this Narration [Darimi 93] in his 📚 Tawassul
Now let's see solitary narration of Sa'id ibn Zayd and how scholars graded it
📚 Musnad Ahmad 20440
• Al-Suyuti : Sahih
• Al-Wadi'i : Hasan
• Shuaib Al-Arnaout : Hasan
• Al-Albani : Hasan
📚 Musnad Ahmad 12627
• Shuaib Al-Arnaout : Hasan
• Al-Albani : Hasan
• Ibn Qayyim : Jayyid [Good]
• Husayn Salim Asad al-Darani : Hasan
The conclusion is that Sa'id Ibn Zayd is Truthful, and his narrations, if not Sahih, are at least "Hasan"
Objection 3️⃣ : Amr ibn Malik al-Nkri is Weak [Da'ef] and his Solitary narrations are not Authentic
Response —
Same as before, some graded him Weak without explanation and did error and mistake but there are many who graded him Trustworthy or Truthful, hence Acceptable
Let's see
Postive Remarks ✅
1) Yahya Ibn Ma'in :
Trustworthy
📚 Sualat Ibn al-Junayd 710
2) Dhahabi :
Trustworthy
📚 Mizan al-I'tidal 3/286, 6436
3) Haythami :
Trustworthy
📚 Majma' al-Zawa'id 16/235
4) Shuayb Al-Arnaut & Bashar Awad :
Hasan al-hadith
📚 Tahrir Taqrib 5104
5) Abd al-Hakim Salih
Hasan al-hadith
📚 Taqrib 5104
6) Hussein Salim Asad al-Darani :
Trustworthy
📚 Musnad al-Darimi, 1/227, 93
7) Albani :
Trustworthy [2 Times]
📚 Fadl as-Salat 'ala an-Nabi p. 88
📚 Silsilat al-Ahadith al-Sahihah, 5/608 2472
Now pay attention to this one because some scholars made mistake which we will see later
8) Ibn Hibban :
[Mentioned him in book of Trustworthy]
He narrated from Abu al-Jawza...His hadith is considered from other than the narration of his son from him
📚 Thiqat 7/228
[These are what objectors present against this narrator, and there are certain points that need to be addressed in each of them. I will address each comment one by one, rather than addressing them collectively for better understanding]
1) Ibn Hajar :
Truthful, but makes mistakes
[Saduq lahu awham]
📚 Taqrib 5104
First of all, this doesn't constitute explained jarh that can override the established tadil. He affirms that he is Truthful and mentions that he had some errors but without specifying those errors
Second, The grading is “Truthful” [Saduq] only, not “makes mistakes” [lahu awham]
When Ibn Hajar mentioned Ibn Hibban’s wording in Tahdhib, he included the additional phrase “yukhti’u wa yughrib” [Makes mistakes & narrates strange reports], which is not found in Ibn Hibban’s Thiqat. As clearly seen from scan page and statement of Ibn Hibban I provided earlier
It is therefore considered a slip of the pen [sabq qalam], upon which Ibn Hajar based his addition “lahu awham.” [Makes Mistakes] in Taqrib. Once this erroneous addition is removed, the basis for “lahu awham” disappears, leaving the correct grading as “Saduq” alone
Reason for his mistake ?
It seems that he confused him with another narrtor with same name —Amr ibn Malik al-Nukri, who is Amr ibn Malik al-Rasibi al-Ghburi, who narrates from Fudayl ibn Sulayman [Not Abu Jawza], about whom Ibn Hibban said “Yughrib wa-yukhti”
📚 Thiqat 8/487
• Arnaut & Bashar Awad :
Ibn Hajar's statement, “He has some errors” it seems that he took this from statement which he mentioned Ibn Hibban said: “yukhti'u wa yughrib”. We didn't find this statement...It seems that he confused him with another person...
📚 Tahrir Taqrib 5104
• Bin Baaz [Former Grand Mufti of KSA] commented on a narration in which our narrtor [Amr ibn Malik al-Nukri] is in chain :
Ibn Hibban (8/487) mentioned biography of another narrator who is also called Amr ibn Malik al-Nukri
and he is the one about whom he said: “Yughrib wa-yukhti-He narrates Strange reports and makes mistakes.” However, Ibn Hibban explicitly states that this al-Nukri was one of his shaykhs’ shaykhs, and he is much later than the narrator [our Narrtor] of the hadith.
Therefore, the correct position is that the additional wording is not found in the narrator of our hadith..
Likewise, al-Samani correctly transmitted it [Without “Yughrib wa-yukhti”] from Ibn Hibban in 📚 al-Ansab 5/522
📚 Al-Durrah al-Yatimah fi Takhrij p.180
• Mehmood Saeed :
Correct wording of Hafiz's is “Truthful” only. Coz in Tahdhib, there is addition to Ibn Hibban’s statement which I didn't find in Thiqat - “yukhtiʾwa-yughrib”. This was slip of pen upon which Hafiz based his statement: “He has some errors”
📚 Rafal-Manarah p.231
He narrates munkar hadiths from trustworthy narrators, and he steals hadiths
And indeed, in addition to what I have mentioned, Amr has other munkar narrations, some of which he stole from trustworthy people
📚 Al-Kamil fi Duafa 6/258-259
This is clear from narrations mentioned by Ibn Adi. Amr ibn Malik al-Nukri is shown narrating from “Fudayl ibn Sulayman” and “Walid ibn Muslim.” Both belong to a much later generation, making it chronologically impossible for Amr to have narrated from them
📚 Al-Kamil 6/258-259
Amr ibn Malik al-Rasibi al-Ghubari...al-Basri
Narrates from...Fudayl ibn Sulayman,...Walid ibn Muslim
I say: Ibn Adi said...However, at the beginning of biography, he said: "Amr ibn Malik al-Nakri," which is a mistake, as al-Nakri predates this
📚 Tahdhib 3/301
• Mehmood Saeed :
Ibn Adi confused Amr ibn Malik al-Nukri with Amr ibn Malik al-Rasibi. He said...However, at beginning of entry he wrote “Amr ibn Malik al-Nukri.” The correct identity is “Amr ibn Malik al-Rasibi”. Ibn Hajar pointed out Ibn Adi's error
📚 Rafal Manarah p.233
He is weak [Deaf]
📚 Al-Kamil 6/258
Again the is not Amr ibn Malik al-Nukri but Amr ibn Malik al-Rasibi because this was mentioned by Ibn Adi where he made the mistake we discussed
[Translation of the red highlighted text mention above]
Ibn Adi : I heard Abu Ya'la say: Amr ibn Malik al-Nukri was weak
• Ibn Hajar that's why mentioned this remark of Abu Yala under the narrator Amr ibn Malik al-Rasibi and Said :
Ibn Adi made mistake, for al-Nakri [Our] precedes this one
📚 Tahdhib 3/301
Even if this Remark is for Our Amr ibn Malik al-Nukri, it's still Unexplained Critisism
4) Other Scholars Who Graded him Weak like Ibn al-jawzi or graded this narration as Fabrication
• Bin baaz :
Ibn al-Jawzi confused Amr ibn Mālik al-Nukri with Amr ibn Malik al-Rasibi, and the latter is very weak
📚 Al-Durrah al-Yatimah fi Takhrij p.180
• Mehmood Saeed :
Number of scholars were misled by Ibn Adi’s confusion, including Ibn al-Jawzi...and Ibn Taymiyyah...As a result, they declared this report to be fabricated, which is an error originating from their following Ibn Adi
📚 Rafal Manarah 233
He is weak [Da'ef]
📚 Masa'il al-Imam Ahmad p.89
My father : [Another Hadith] There is disagreement regarding its Isnad; it has not been established according to me. “And it seems that he regarded Amr ibn Malik as weak”
Note - It "seems", also it's unexplained
Now let's see a solitary narration of Amr ibn Malik al-Nukri and how scholars graded it
📚 Sahih Ibn Hibban 401
• Ibn Hibban : Sahih
• Hakim : Sahih
• Dhahabi : Sahih
• Ibn Khuzaymah : Sahih
• Ahmad Shakir : Sahih
• Al-Albani : Sahih
Objection 4️⃣ : Abu al-Jawza Is Trustworthy but his Narrations from Ayesha is not connected hence it's Mursal [Disconnected Report]
• Ibn Adi :
He didn't hear from the likes of Ibn Mas'ud, Aisha, and others
• Ibn Abd al-Barr :
He didn't hear from her
📚 Tahdib 1/194
Musaddad narrated to us from Jafar ibn Sulayman, from Amr ibn Malik al-Nakri, from Abu al-Jawza, who said:
I stayed with Ibn Abbas and Aishah for 12 yrs. There was not a single verse of Quran except that I asked them about it
📚 Tarikh al-Kabir 2/16-17
Here he didn't mention the problem
So Ibn Adi Said it's disconnection between Abu al Jawza and Ayesha
However Ibn Hajar clarified that, it's Amr ibn Malik al-Nukri who is weak in Bukhari's view
📚 Tahdib 1/194
And we have already established the trustworthiness of Amr ibn Malik al-Nukri and also seen his solitary narrations
Hence that narration of Imam Bukhari is Authentic [As for his Critisism/Weaking of al-Nukri, it's Unexplained]
Objection - Abu al-Jawza sent a messenger to Aayesha
• Ibn Hajar said :
This indicates that he didn't meet her face-to-face. However, there is no impediment to possibility that he went to her afterward and met her face-to-face, according to Muslim's view
📚 Tahdhib 1/194
Abu al Jawza Heard from Ayesha
📚 al-Jam bayna Rijal al-Sahihayn 1/46
Abu al Jawza Heard from Ayesha
📚 Jami al-Usul fi Ahadith al-Rasul 12/183
Abu al-Jawza...Highly trustworth. His hearing from Ayesha cannot be denied, and the scholars [al-Jamaah : Core authors of the major Hadith books] have used him as evidence
📚 Nasb al-Rayah li-Ahadith 1/334
Abu al Jawza Heard from Ayesha
📚 Mirqat al-Mafatih Sharh Mishkat 11/95, 5950
📚 Sahih Muslim 498
Whenever a trustworthy man narrates a hadith from another trustworthy man, and it is possible for him to have met him and heard from him because both of them lived in same era, then narration is established and it is binding to use it as evidence, even if there is
No report establishing that two of them actually met or spoke to one another...
As long as circumstances b/w them remain within possibility we explained, Narration is always treated as one based upon hearing, until there is evidence establishing otherwise
📚 Sahih Muslim
Therefore, all the points mentioned above are sufficient to refute the objection that the chain is disconnected
Objection 5️⃣ : Ibn Taymiyyah said : during the entire life of Ayesha, there was no such hole in the roof of the Prophet’s tomb
Response —
A traditionist and historian from Medina, Ali bin Ahmad Samhudi has disconfirmed Ibn Taymiyyah and supported Imam Darimi's Narration
• Al-Zayn al-Maraghi said:
“Know that opening the aperture during times of drought has been the practice of the people of Madinah up to the present day. They open an aperture at the lower part of the dome of the chamber—that is, the sacred blue dome—on the side facing the qiblah
even though the roof comes between the Noble Grave and the sky.”
I [Samhudi] say: Their practice today is to open the door facing the Noble Face from the enclosure surrounding the chamber and to gather there.
📚 Wafa' al-Wafa 2/320
Scholar's Authentication
Now let's see some scholars who graded this Narration as Authentic and Those who accepted it as Tawassul/Intercession after Passing of Rasoolallah
• Imam Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani :
HASAN
📚 Hidayat al-Ruwah ila Takhrij Ahadith al-Masabih wa al-Mishkat, 1/58 [Grading Methodology: Silence=Hasan], 5/362 [Narration]
The grading of Ameerul Momineen fil Hadith, Imam Ibn Hajar is Sufficient for us. ALHAMDULILLAH
1) Dorar dorar.net/h/1WT2Sghe
2) Hdith hdith.com/h/7Z791WMLF_
“HASAN"
📚 Masabih al-Sunnah 1/59-60 [Methodology, Silence=Sahih/Hasan], 4/128, 4657 [Narration]
“Sahih/Hasan [Acceptable Authenticity]”
📚 al-Wafa 1/166-167 [Methodology : He said : I do not mix the sound hadith with the false and For in the Sound hadith there is sufficiency], 4/360, 1486 [Narration]
“Salih [Acceptable]”
He said : The Chain of transmission for the hadith of this chapter is acceptable [salih]...because I have not seen anyone who weakened it based on a valid proof
📚 Fath Al-Mannan 1/558,564, no.98
“Jayyid [Good]”
He said : This chain of narration is acceptable; in fact, I consider it to be good
📚 Shifa ul fuad bi ziyarat p.107,108
“HASAN”
📚 Rafal Manarah p.228
• Imam Subki
He used this Narration Against the argument of those who says, Umar didn't go to grave or use Waseela of Rasoolallah after his Passing
This clearly shows his approval of the narration as Acceptable
📚 Shifa al Siqaam p.377-378
Under section “Seeking intercession through him after his death”
And explained “One seeks intercession through him by asking him for that matter, meaning that he is able to cause it through his supplication and intercession to his Lord”
📚 Wafa al-Wafa 5/68,70
• Mulla Ali Qari :
Intercession was sought through him during times of drought, and heavens would rain. Aisha ordered his grave to be uncovered to emphasize the importance of seeking intercession through him...
📚 Mirqat al-Mafatih 11/95-96
Correct term is intercession by his grave, coz they used to seek rain through him during his lifetime. So I ordered his grave be uncovered, and sky rained as if they had sought rain through his grave after his death
📚 Al-Mu'at al-Tanqih 11/519-520
It is also possible that unveiling is like a means [Waseela] to Allah for rain. Just as he was alive and his prayers for rain were answered immediately, so too is it when rain is sought through him after his death
📚 Mafatih fi Sharh Masabih 6/271,272