Menu

Authentication of Narration of RasoolAllah ﷺ and Ibn Umar : Recommended recitation of Quran at Grave

Part 1 ) Narration/Hadith of RasoolAllah ﷺ


Abd al-Rahman ibn al-Ala ibn al-Lajlaj narreted from his father

My father said to me: 'O my son, when I die, bury me in a niche grave. When you place me in my niche, say: "In the name of God and upon the creed of the Messenger of God." Then scatter the soil over me gently. Then recite at my head the opening of al-Baqarah and its conclusion, for I heard the Messenger of God say that.'

📚 Al-Mu'jam al-Kabir 19/220-221, Hadith no. 491


> Chain of Transmission [Isnad] —

The last/common portion of all three chains is:

→ Mubashshir ibn Ismail

→ Abd al-Rahman ibn al-Ala ibn al-Lajlaj

→ al-Ala ibn al-Lajlaj
[Father of Abd al-Rahman]

→ Al-Lajlaj Abu Khalid [Companion]
[Father of al-Ala]


Objection 1️⃣ : Abd al-Rahman ibn al-Ala ibn al-Lajlaj is Majhul [Unknown]


Response —

This is a lie
No rijal scholar has ever said this

He is known

Imam Ibn Hajar :

• Resident of Aleppo [Sham]
• From the seventh generation

📚 Taqrib al-Tahdhib 3975

Imam al-Mizzi

• Also know as al-Amiri al-Shami 
• Nephew of Khalid ibn al-Lajlaj
• Used to reside in Halab [Aleppo]
• Narrated from his father, al-Ala ibn al-Lajlaj
• Narrated from him Mubashshir ibn Ismail al-Halabi

📚 Tahdhib al-Kamal 3925

Objection 2️⃣ : Abd al-Rahman ibn al-Ala ibn al-Lajlaj is Majhul al-ayn 


Means whose reliability has not been established, and from whom only one narrator is known to have transmitted

As Imam Dhahabi said : No one narrated from him except Mubashir ibn Ismail

Response —

Again This is a lie

No rijal scholar has ever Classified him under Majhul al-ayn or just Mujhul

And as for Imam Dhahabi, where exactly did he mention him as Majhul?

All he said was that, No one narrated from him except Mubashir 

So What ?

The objectors presented partial definition of Majhul al-ayn 

Here is the actual definition/Usool

Imam Ibn Hajar :

• If the narrator is named, and only one narrator transmits from him, then he is Majhul al-Ayn , like the Mubham (unnamed narrator) “UNLESS SOMEONE OTHER THAN THE PERSON WHO ALONE NARRATES FROM HIM DECLARES HIM TRUSTWORTHY, ACCORDING TO STRONGER OPINION.”

📚 Sharh Nukhbat al-Fikar fi Mustalah Ahl al-Athar 1/98

And we do have Scholars who Authenticated [Tawthiq] the Narrator, Hence he is not Majhul al-ayn

Authentication [Tawthiq] of Abd al-Rahman ibn al-Ala ibn al-Lajlaj


1) Ibn Hibban : 

• Mentioned him in Kitab al-Thiqat [TRUSTWORTHY]

📚 Kitab al-Thiqat 7/90

2) Nur al-Din al-Haythami :

• Commented on a chain and said, It's Narrators are TRUSTWORTHY

📚 Majma al-Zawaid 4292


3) Muhammad ibn Yusuf al-Salihi :

• Commented on a chain and said, It's Narrators are TRUSTWORTHY

📚 Subul al-Huda 8/379


These Three Authentication are very explicit and are enough for the Narrator and his narrations to be Authentic

Other Gradings

1) Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani :

• Maqbul [Acceptable]

📚 Taqrib al-Tahdhib 3975

2) Al-Mubarakfuri

• Maqbul [Acceptable]

📚 Tuhfat al-Ahwadhi 4/56


3) Abd al-Hakim Salih :

• Salih [Reliable] al-hadith
• No criticism of him was mentioned

📚 Taqrib al-Tahdhib 3975


> Bonus : Imam Ahmad and Yahya ibn Main

Both cited a narration transmitted through Abd al-Rahman ibn al-Ala ibn al-Lajlaj as evidence. Their use of his narration as evidence indicates that they did not regard his transmission as problematic in that context. This can therefore be cited as implicit acceptance (taqbul) of his narration, even though it is not an explicit statement of tawthiq. [See section 12 : Scholar's Authentication 6th - 7th ]

Objection 3️⃣ : Ibn Hibban was lenient, Hence not acceptable 


[This is why Albani didn't accept the authentication of narrator by Imam Ibn Hibban]

Response —

First of all, I have presented Two other scholars' explicit authentication besides him

Second, his leniency has no effect as the narrator is not unknown and no one has ever criticized him also scholars used his narration as evidence

Hence his Authentication is Valid

> Bonus : Hypocrisy of Albani 

1) Albani commented on authentication of a Narrator Ruh ibn Salah by Imam Ibn Hibban and Hakim and said :

Ibn Hibban is lenient in declaring narrators trustworthy, for he frequently declares unknown narrators trustworthy...Al-Hakim is similarly lenient, as is evident to one well-versed in the science of biographies and narrators. "THEREFORE, WHEN THEIR STATEMENTS CONFLICT [WITH THE CRITICISM OF OTHER SCHOLARS], THEIR STATEMENTS ARE NOT GIVEN ANY WEIGHT, EVEN IF THE CRITICISM IS UNEXPLAINED [GHAYR MUFASSAR]

📚 Silsilat al-Ahadith al-Da'if 1/80


Note - Albani’s criticism is specifically in the case of contradiction. Therefore, it is clear from his wording that when there is no contradiction, he does not deny weight to Ibn Hibban’s or al-Hakim’s authentication.

As for Abd al-Rahman ibn al-Ala ibn al-Lajlaj, he has been authenticated by Ibn Hibban, al-Haythami, and Yusuf al-Salihi and accepted by Ibn Hajar. Moreover, Imam Ahmad and Yahya ibn Main both used narration through him as evidence, further indicating that there is no contradiction regarding his status.

Hypocrisy -
He deemed this narration Weak, even when Ibn Hibban's authentication has no contradiction

And If there is any conflicting criticism from even a single rijal scholar [not modern], then bring it to us. However they can't, because it doesn't exists.

2) He authenticated a narration in which a narrator Malik al dar, has no authentication except for Imam Ibn Hibban, And used his authentication of narrator to authenticate the narration as HASAN

📚 Targhib wal Tarhib 1326


This is why Sheikh Mehmood Saeed said:

So you see him authenticating and weakening [narrations] according to his school of thought (bias), and for this reason, contradictions abound from him and he abandons the established rules

See more such examples in Objection 4 section where he authenticated narration's from allegedly Majhul narrators 

Objection 4️⃣ : Ibn Hajar Graded him as Maqbul [Acceptable] hence his Solitary narrations are unauthentic 


Response —

How exactly does Ibn Hajar grading precedes other three scholars's explicit Tawthiq ?

Infact, The Tawthiq take precedence and we aren't bound to garde him Maqbul

Second thing is that, Yes we do have another supporting narration for cooroboration

However, I am going to show you that even without corroboration, reports from narrators who were declared "Maqbul" by Ibn Hajar or Majhul by other, have been graded Hasan/Sahih by many scholars

Consider these two examples:

1) Muti ibn Rashid al-Basri


📚 Sunan Abu Dawud 197

Grade -

• Albani : Hasan
• Shuayb al-Arnaut : Hasan
• Hafiz Zubayr Ali Zai : Hasan
• Imam Ibn Hajar Al-'Asqalani : Hasan

2) Muhammad ibn Abdullah ibn Maymun ibn Misika

📚 Sunan Abu Dawud 3628


Grade -

• Albani : Hasan
• Shuayb al-ArnautArnaut : Hasan
• Hafiz Zubayr Ali Zai : Hasan
• Imam Hakim : Sahih
• Imam Dhahabi : Sahih
• Imam Ibn Hajar : Hasan


You can clearly see that even Ibn Hajar himself graded narrations as Hasan despite Grading the narrator as Maqbul

In Part 2, you will see Ibn Hajar grading a similar Narration via Abd al-Rahman as Hasan

Scholar's Authentication


let's see scholars who Authenticated this Narration/Hadith of RasoolAllah

1) Husayn Salim Asad al-Dalani :

“This is a Good [Hasan] chain of transmission, there is nothing wrong with it”

📚 Majma al-Zawaid 6/489, 4292

2) Abdullah ibn Muhammad ibn al-Siddiq al-Ghumari :

“I say: Its chain of narration is good [Hasan]”

📚 Itqan al-Sun'ah fi Tahqiq Ma'na al-Bid'ah p.110

3) Hassan bin Ali al-Saqqaf :

 “I say: Rather, it is an authentic [Sahih] hadith”

📚 Sahih Sifat Salat an-Nabi min al-Takbir ila al-Taslim Ka'annaka Tanzuru Ilayha p.243

Supporting Narration 


Now let's see the supporting narration

This Narration is weak in its own [independently] because of the two weak narrators

1) Yahya b. Abdullah al-Bablutti
2) Ayyub b. Nahik

However they were not accused of Lying and Fabrication, hence can be used for corroboration

→ Abu Shuayb al-Harrania
→ Yahya b. Abdullah al-Bablutti
→ Ayyub b. Nahik
→ Ața b. Abu Rabāh
→ Ibn Umar

Ibn Umar reported, 

I heard the Prophet say: "When any of you dies, do not hold him back, and hasten with him to his grave, and let the opening of the Book (al-Fatihah) be recited at his head and the closing of al-Baqarah at his feet in his grave."

📚 Al-Mu'jam al-Kabir 12/444 Hadith no. 13613

Scholar's Authentication


1) Imam Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani :

“Narrated by al-Tabarani with a good [Hasan] chain of transmission”

📚 Fath al-Bari 6/658-659


2) Muhammad ibn Ali al-Shawkani :

“Narrated with a good [Hasan] chain of transmission”

📚 Nayl al-Awtar 7/389

3) Al-Hasan bin Ahmad al-Ruba'i al-San'ani :

“Narrated by al-Tabarani with a good [Hasan] chain of transmission”

📚 Fath al-Ghaffar 1/743

4) Imam Badr al-Din al-Ayni

“al-Tabarani narrated with a good [Hasan] chain of transmission”

📚 Umdat al-Qari Sharh Sahih al-Bukhari 8/164

5) Hassan bin Ali al-Saqqaf :

 “Weak chain of transmission, but it is good [Hasan] due to supporting evidence”

📚 Sahih Sifat Salat an-Nabi min al-Takbir ila al-Taslim Ka'annaka Tanzuru Ilayha p.243

> Conclusion

The First narration is Authentic [Sahih/Hasan] independently as the narrator has been authenticated by Rijal scholars 

However it also has Supporting narration, so if it's not independently authentic then it's at least Hasan li-ghayrihi [due to corroboration]

Part 2) Narration of Ibn Umar رضي الله عنه


Abd al-Rahman ibn al-Ala ibn al-Lajlaj reported from this father

He said to his son, "When you put me in the grave and put me in the niche, then say: 'Bismillah wa 'ala sunnati rasulillahi (In the name of Allah and according to the Sunnah of the Messenger of Allah).' Then throw the soil on me and recite from the beginning of Surah al-Baqarah and from its end near my head." He said: I saw Ibn 'Umar (may Allah be pleased with them both) considered it desirable.

📚 Sunan al-Kubra 4/94, Hadith No. 7068

Objections


Same as before, coz it has same chain of transmission at the end

→ Mubashshir ibn Ismail

→ Abd al-Rahman ibn al-Ala ibn al-Lajlaj

→ al-Ala ibn al-Lajlaj

[However al-Lajlaj is not present]

Response —

Already covered in Part 1 in Narration/Hadith of RasoolAllah

> Quick Recap

Don’t get confused

Part 1 — Narration of RasoolAllah

It's father of al-Ala, i.e. al-Lajlaj Abu Khalid (Companion), who heard from RasoolAllah

Part 2 — Narration of Ibn Umar

It's the son of al-Lajlaj Abu Khalid, i.e. al-Ala, who said that he saw Ibn Umar recommending it

Scholar's Authentication


Now let's see the scholars who either Authenticated this Narration of Ibn Umar or Used it as Evidence considering it as Authentic or Acceptable

1) Imam al-Nawawi :

“We have Narrated in Sunan al-Bayhaqi with a good [Hasan] chain of transmission”

📚 Kitab al-Adhkar p.278

2) Imam Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani :

“This is Mawquf Hasan [Good]”

📚 Nata'ij al-Afkar fi Takhrij Ahadith al-Adhkar 4/426

3) Imam al-Bayhaqi :

“This is Mawquf Hasan [Good]”

📚 Kitab al-Da'wat al-Kabir 2/297, Hadith No. 638

4) Yusuf bin Majid bin Abi al-Majd al-Maqdisi al-Hanbali :

“Narrated by al-Bayhaqi with a good [Hasan] chain of transmission”

📚 Al-Muqarrar 'ala Abwab al-Muharra 1/417, 888


5) Muhammad bin Illan as-Siddiqi :

Agreed with Hasan [Good] Mawquf grading of Imam Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani by Quoting him

📚 Al-Futuhat ar-Rabbaniyyah 4/194


6) Imam Ahmad :

Ibn Qudamah reports, Imam Ahmad initially regarded recitation at grave as bidʿah. However, when presented with report narrated by Mubashshir of Ibn Umar, he said: “Go back and tell the man to recite.” and retracted his earlier position

📚 al-Mughni 3/518

7) Imam Yahya Ibn Ma'in :

He used this Narration of Ibn Umar as an evidence to recite Quran at Grave when he was asked about recitation of the Quran at grave

📚 Sunan al-Kubra 4/94, Hadith No. 7068


Now here comes one of the greatest and Most beloved Imam of Wahabiyya/Salafis/Ahle Hadith/Najdis

Muhammad ibn Abdul Wahab al-Najdi :

“al-Bayhaqi - with a good [Hasan] chain of transmission”

📚 Majmu'at al-Hadith 'ala Abwab 2/303