Menu

Authentication of the narration of Abu Ayub al-Ansari : Placing his Face on GRAVE of RasoolAllah

Narration of Abu Ayub al-Ansari


❝Sahabi Abu Ayyub al-Ansari placing his Face on GRAVE of RasoolAllah ﷺ. When confronted by Marwan, he rebuked him, affirming that he had come to court of RasoolAllah, not to a stone❞

> Complete Narration :

One day Marwan came and found a man placing his face upon the grave. He grabbed him by the neck and said, ‘Do you know what you are doing?

The man replied, ‘Yes.’

When Marwan turned toward him, he found that it was Abu Ayyub al-Ansari 

He said: ‘I came to the Messenger of Allah ﷺ, and I did not come to a stone. I heard the Messenger of Allah ﷺ say: “Do not weep over the religion when its people are in charge of it; rather, weep over it when those who are not its people are in charge of it.”

📚 Al-Mustadrak ala al-Sahihayn, 4/560, Hadith number 8571


📚 Musnad Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal, 17/42-43, Hadith number 23476


> Note : 

Some books of Hadith only mention the Prophetic Hadith part because the narration was abridged and author omitted the Historical Athar part

However, the original narration contains both the Historical Athar and the Prophetic Hadith within the same chain of narration

First thing which you should know is that this narration of Imam Ahmad and al-Hakim has two parts :

1) Historical Athar : Incident, actions, and words of Companion

2) Prophetic Hadith : Statement of the Prophet ﷺ, transmitted by the Companion


> Source of this Article :

THE AUTHENTICITY OF THE SAHABI ABU AYYUB AL-ANSARI’S ACTIONS AT THE GRAVE OF THE NOBLE PROPHET [Link]

By Dr. Abul Hasan Hussain Ahmed

> Chain of Narration [Isnad] :

• Abu al-Abbas Muhammad ibn Yaqub
• al-Abbas ibn Muhammad ibn Hatim al-Duri
• Abu Amir Abd al-Malik ibn Amr al-Aqdi
• Kathir ibn Zayd
• Dawud ibn Abi Salih


Let's Begin

Objection 1️⃣ : Kathir ibn Zayd is Da'ef [Weak]


Response —

Only few scholars criticized him, and only Imam al-Nasai explicitly declared him weak. However, other scholars did not find any significant fault in him and considered him to be Truthful or even Thiqah [Trustworthy]

Negative Remarks ❌

• Nasai : Weak

• Abu Zura : Truthful, but there is weakness 

• Yaqub ibn Shaybah : He is not severely weak, though he tends toward weakness

• Abu Hatim al-Razi : Salih, he is not strong, his hadith is written down 

📚 Tahdhib al-Tahdhib 3/458-459


Postive Remarks ✅

• Imam Ahmad : I do not see any problem with him

• Ibn Hibban : Mentioned him in Thiqat

• Ibn Adi : I have not seen any problem with him, and I hope that there is no problem with him

• Ibn Ammar al-Mawsili : Trustworthy

• Yahya ibn Main : There is no problem with him [Though he also criticized him previously]

📚 Tahdhib al-Tahdhib 3/458-459


• Mughlatay ibn Qilij : And many of the people of knowledge narrated from Kathir, so they accepted his hadith [He also Quoted Imam Ahmad]

📚 Al-Ilam bi-Sunnatihi Alayhi al-Salah wa al-Salam: Sharh Sunan Ibn Majah 1/338


• Shuayb Al-Arnaut : Rather he is Saduq [Truthful] and Hasan Al-Hadith [good in narrating] just as Al-Busayri stated in his Misbaah Az-Zujaajah

📚 Tahrir Taqrib al-Tahdhib 5611, 3/192

• Al-Busayri : considered Kathir to be from the Thiqat [Trustworthy]

He commented on the chain and said "This chain has Trustworthy [Thiqat] narrators

📚 [Misbah Az-Zujaajah] Zawaid Ibn Majah ala al-Kutub al-Sittah 336, 1/160

• Al-Hakim : I do not know him to be criticized in narration

📚 Al-Mustadrak 146, 1/110

Also said: Kathir ibn Zayd and Abu Abdillah al-Qarra are two Medinan narrators. We know nothing about them except Truthfulness

📚 Al-Mustadrak 790, 1/338


• Haythami : Considered Kathir to be from the Thiqat [Trustworthy]

He commented on chain and said "Ahmad narrated it, and its men [narrators] are authenticated/Trustworthy."

📚 Majma al-Zawaid 1789, 4/134-135


• Albani : He is Hasan ul-Hadith

📚 Silsilah al-Ahaadeeth as-Saheehah 3/121


He also commented on a Chain and said : Its narrators are Trustworthy. There is some discussion about Kathir ibn Zayd but it does not harm [The Hadith]

📚 Mishkatul Masabih 1/536

• Hafiz Zubayr Ali Zai : Kathir ibn Zayd is Hasan ul-Hadith 

📚 Sunan Abu Dawud 5173, 4/850-851


Objection 2️⃣ : Imam Ibn Hajar Al-'Asqalani Said : Kathir ibn Zayd is “Saduq Yukhti” [Truthful with Mistakes]


📚 Taqrib al-Tahdhib 1/808

Hence his solitary narrations cannot be accepted

Response —

Yes, it's True that he mentioned this. However that's not the only thing he said

He later specifically declared Kathir ibn Zayd to be: Saduq [Truthful] and dropped Yukthti [Mistakes]

📚 Nata’ij al-Afkar 1/229

[This grading of just Saduq [Truthful] was made by Ibn Hajar some 21 Hijri years after his initial grading of Saduq yukhti in 817 AH]

And In the same book, ibn Hajar declared Kathir ibn Zayd to be from the muwathhaqun [Tustworthy]

He commented on a narration and said :

The narrators of this chain of transmission have been declared trustworthy

📚 Nata’ij al-Afkar 4/381

[That was his final gradation]


And even if we take his Final Grading as "Truthful with mistakes" even then this doesn't harm the narration as he himself graded solitary narrations from Kathir ibn Zayd [See next section]

Hence at least he is Hasan ul-Hadith as Shuayb al-Arnaut said in edition of Taqrib al-Tahdhib [mentioned before]

Objection 3️⃣ : Solitary narrations of Kathir ibn Zayd are Weak


In Sihah Sittah, narrations of Kathir ibn Zayd occur frequently, But, those narrations have other chains; hence, due to corroboration [due to Support], his narrations are graded Authentic. Hence solitary narrations are Weak

Response —

No, this is not true

let's see the gradings of different scholars on narrations in which Kathir ibn Zayd is part of the chain and for which no other known chain exists without him; hence, no corroboration

• Imam Bukhari : Hadith is Sahih
• Imam Tirmidhi: Hadith is Hasan Gharib
• Hafiz Zubayr Ali Zai : Hasan

📚 Tirmidhi 1579a


• Imam Ibn Hibban : Sahih

📚 Sahih Ibn Hibban 7262

This refutes the claim that Ibn Hibban was merely lenient in mentioning Kathir ibn Zayd in Thiqat. By grading this hadith Sahih through Kathir ibn Zayd, it becomes clear that his inclusion of him was not merely due to leniency


• Imam Hakim : Sahih
• Imam Dhahabi : Sahih
• Imam al-Haythami : Hasan

📚 Al-Mustadrak 7602, Musnad Ahmad 14564, Majma al-Zawaid 17543


• Albani : Hasan
• Shuayb al-Arnaut : Hasan
• Hafiz Zubayr Ali Zai : Hasan
• Abdul Qadir Arna’ut : Hasan
• Imam Zaynud-Din al-Iraqi : Hasan
• Isam Hadi : Hasan
• Abdur Rauf al-Munawi : Hasan
• Amir al-San’ani : Hasan

📚 Sunan Abu Dawud 4918


Now Let's see Imam Ibn Hajar Al-'Asqalani's gradations

The Above narration [Abu Dawood 4918] : Hasan

📚 Bulugh al-Maram 1549, 1/460

He also graded a narration via Kathir ibn Zayd : Sahih

📚 Al-Mataalib al-Aaliyah 3943, 16/142

There is one more, but we will see that later


Objection 4️⃣ : Jarh [criticism] takes precedence over Tadil [praise]


Since some scholars made Jarh [criticism] against Kathir ibn Zayd, Jarh takes precedence over Tadil [praise]. Therefore, Kathir ibn Zayd is weak

Response —

It is true that, in principle, Jarh takes precedence over Tadil. However this principle is subject to an important condition : 

The Jarh [Criticism] must be explained [mufassar]. If the Jarah is unexplained [Ghayr mufassar] it does not override the Tadil [praise] of the scholars who declared the narrator trustworthy

Those who weaken Kathir didn't explain the reason behind it

Imam Ibn Hajar Al-'Asqalani, explains that jarh is only preferred over tadil when it is explained and issued by a qualified critic. Otherwise, it is not accepted against an established trustworthy narrator

📚 Sharh Nukhbat al-Fikar fi Mustalah Ahl al-Athar 1/139

• Abdul Aziz ibn Baz [Saudi grand Mufti] :

A group of Imams have deemed him [Kathir] trustworthy, and some criticized him without explanation [Jarh ghayr mufassar], therefore the author [Imam Ibn Hajar] relied on his Truthfulness

📚 Al-Taliq ala Taqrib al-Tahdhib 1/155


Conclusion —

Kathir ibn Zayd is At least Hasan ul Hadith and his narrations are authentic even without Corroboration [Support]

Objection 5️⃣ : Dawud ibn abi Salih is fabricator


Dawud ibn abi Salih, in this chain is Dawud ibn abi Salih al-laythi. Ibn Hibban said: fabricator and Ibn hajar said: Munkar [rejected]

Response —

This is an Absurd claim in order to weaken this Narration. No scholar ever said it's Dawud ibn abi Salih al-laythi

Imam Ibn Hajar Al-'Asqalani discusses the very narration recorded by Imam Ahmad and al-Hakim under the biography of Dawud ibn Abi Salih al-Hijazi, not al-Laythi and said he narrated from Abu Ayyub ansari

📚 Tahdhib al-Tahdhib 2119, 2/356


That's why even in Sunnah.com Kathir ibn Zayd is mentioned as the student of Dawud ibn Abi Salih al-Hijazi, not al-Laythi and Abu Ayyub al-Ansari as teacher of Dawud ibn Abi Salih al-Hijazi again not al-Laythi

Objection 6️⃣ : Dawud ibn Abi Salih is Majhul [Unknown]


Dawud ibn Abi Salih al-Hijazi, was declared unknown [majhul] by Dhahabi. Therefore, Dhahabi's grading of narration as authentic despite this judgment is contradictory. Hence chain is weak

Response —

According to his methodology, unknown is not always rejected

He himself explains, Reports of unknown narrators from the senior or middle generation of the Tabiun are accepted and received with a favorable presumption, provided they do not contradict established principles or contain awkward wordings

📚 Diwan al-Du'afa 1/478

And he graded many narrations of al-Hakim as Sahih, despite saying that the narrator is unknown. So, that's not an error or a contradiction at all. The narrator might be unknown but from the senior or middle Tabiun

And that's not the only garding Dawud Ibn abi Salih al-hijaji has got

Imam Ibn Hajar Al-'Asqalani graded him "Maqbul" [Acceptable] and said, he is from the 3rd Generation [Middle Tabiun]

📚 Taqrib al-Tahdhib 1792, 1/186

Objection 7️⃣ : Narration of a Maqbul [Acceptable] narrator needs corroboration


The narration of a Maqbul [Acceptable] narrator is authentic only when it is corroborated [by supporting narrations]. Therefore, this narration is weak and rejected

Response —

Yes, we have a corroborating report too, which will strengthen this narration

However, I am going to show you that even without corroboration, reports from "unknown narrators" who were declared "Maqbul" by Ibn Hajar have been graded Hasan/Sahih by many scholars

Consider these two examples:

1) Muti ibn Rashid al-Basri


📚 Sunan Abu Dawud 197


Grade -

• Albani : Hasan
• Shuayb al-Arnaut : Hasan
• Hafiz Zubayr Ali Zai : Hasan
• Imam Ibn Hajar Al-'Asqalani : Hasan


2) Muhammad ibn Abdullah ibn Maymun ibn Misika


📚 Sunan Abu Dawud 3628






Grade -

• Albani : Hasan
• Shuayb al-ArnautArnaut : Hasan
• Hafiz Zubayr Ali Zai : Hasan
• Imam Hakim : Sahih
• Imam Dhahabi : Sahih
• Imam Ibn Hajar : Hasan


Conclusion —

So, even without corroboration, this chain of narration is at least Hasan, if not Sahih, and scholars have graded it likewise, as we will see later

Moreover, we have another chain, which is mentioned by Imam Taqi al-Din al-Subki

Abul-Husayn Yahya ibn Al-Hasan ibn Ja’far ibn Ubaydulla Al-Husayni, in “Akhbaar Al-Medinah” reports with

Umar ibn Khalid>
Abu Nubaatah [Yunus ibn Yahya]>
Kathir ibn Zayd>
Al-Muttalib ibn Abdullah ibn Hantab

Marwan ibn al-Hakam came...[Narration]

📚 Shifa al-siqam 1/342-343


Objection 8️⃣ : Narration of Al-Mutallib is Mursal/Munqati [Disconnected]


Ibn Hajar said about Al-Mutallib : Truthful, frequent Tadlis and Mursal [Disconnected] Narration. Hence this Chain is Weak too

Response —

In this narration, he is not narrating directly from the Prophet. Rather, he says, "Abu Ayyub al-Ansari said..." [Hadith]

Mursal has two usages:

1. Specific [Technical] :

A Tabi narrates directly from the Prophet, omitting the Companion

2. General :

Any disconnected narration [Munqati], including a narrator relating from someone he did not hear from

In this Narration it could be 2nd one

That depends on whether Al-Muttalib met and heard from Abu Ayyub al-Ansari or not

However, scholars differ on this issue. Some say he 
did not hear from any Companion, while others say he heard from Umar, others say Ibn Umar 

However this doesn't harm this Chain of narration

And regarding Ibn Hajar's accusation of Tadlis, Shuyab al-Arnaut clarified :

No one accused him of practicing tadlis. Rather, it appears that by tadlis they intended irsal [Mursal: disconnected narrations]

📚 Tahrir Taqrib al-Tahdhib 6710, 3/386

Now, look at this narration. At the end, it has same chain of narrators:

Kathir ibn Zayd → Al-Muttalib

This narration is also Mursal [2nd Type] as Al-Muttalib was not a Companion, yet he narrates an action of the Prophet through an unknown narrator

📚 Sunan Abu Dawud 3206

Regarding Al-Muttalib's hearing, let's assume the worst ,that he didn't hear from any companions

So, for any narration to be authentic, the least possible scenario would be

Al-Muttalib
↓
Individual 1 [Who heard from Companion]
↓
Individual 2 [Companion]
↓
Prophet

Here is an illustrative comparison chart of the narration of Abu Ayub al-Ansari from Al-Muttalib and the narration of Abu Dawud 3206

As you can see, the “Alleged defect” is more severe in the narration of Abu Dawud

Now, read what Ibn Hajar said regarding Abu Dawud 3206 :

Its chain of narration is HASAN. There is no issue except Kathir, who narrates it from Al-Muttalib, & he is Truthful. Al-Muttalib clarified, an informant informed him, but he didn't name him. HOWEVER, ANONYMITY OF COMPANION DOES NOT CAUSE ANY HARM

📚 Talkhis al-Habir 793, 2/307


Here is the interesting thing: the person who informed Al-Muttalib about this action of the Prophet personally witnessed the event; therefore, he was a Companion.

So, the chain of narration would be:

Al-Muttalib
↓
Individual 1 [Unknown Companion]
↓
Prophet

To grade this narration as Hasan, Ibn Hajar necessarily accepted that Al-Muttalib received this report directly from an unnamed Companion

In our case, however, the Companion is Abu Ayub al-Ansari, not an unknown Companion, yet Objectors grade this narration as weak

Look who else besides Imam Ibn Hajar, graded it Hasan

Albani : Hasan
Shuayb al-Arnaut : Hasan
Hafiz Zubayr Ali Zai : Hasan

So, based on the same principle [usul], this narration of Abu Ayub al-Ansari should be Hasan, if not Sahih

Then Why this hypocrisy?

Now regarding this Narration of Al-Muttalib there are only 4 possibilities as how did he get to know about this incident of Abu Ayub al-Ansari [Athar] and his Saying of RasoolAllah [Hadith]

Analysis of How al-Muttalib Knew the Incident —

Abu Ayyub al-Ansari: d. 52 AH

Marwan ibn al-Hakam: d. 65 AH

Al-Muttalib ibn Abd Allah ibn Hantab: d. 120 AH

Since al-Muttalib's birth year is unknown, it is possible that he lived 90–100 years, making him contemporary with Abu Ayyub and Marwan.

If he lived only 60–70 years, that wouldn't be the case. Hence chronology neither proves nor disproves direct transmission

The 4 Possibilittiees :

1. He witnessed the incident

Possible

If true, the chain is connected

2. He heard it from Abu Ayyub al-Ansari.

Also possible

If true, the chain is connected

Moreover, Ibn Hajar graded Abu Dawud 3206 as Hasan despite the Companion being unknown, stating that the anonymity of the Companion who informed al-Muṭṭalib does not harm the chain. Here, the Companion is identified

3. He heard it directly from Marwan ibn al-Hakam 

[Marwan lived until 65 AH, was al-Muttalib's maternal uncle, and is the central figure in the narration]

Also possible

If true, the chain is connected

4. Someone else informed al-Muṭṭalib

This person could have been:

4a) Unknown Companion → Connected

4b) known Companion → Connected

4c) Trustworthy intermediary → Connected 

4d) Weak/Problematic intermediary → Not Connected and Requires corroboration

& Here comes supporting narration via Dawud ibn Abi Salih al-Hijazi [Discussed before]

Objection 9️⃣ : Other chains didn't mention Grave of Prophet, Hence contradiction


There are 4 different chains of narration. All 4 have Kathir ibn Zayd as the common narrator [In 3 chains he narrates from Al-Muttalib, and in 1 from Dawud]

However, all 4 chains have different wording, and some do not even mention the Grave of Prophet

Response —

Mere differences in wording do not constitute a contradiction. In hadith transmission, omission and rephrasing are well-known. The relevant question is whether the narrations contradict one another, not whether every narrator mentions every detail

Across all four routes, the Prophetic Hadith remains unchanged. The variations occur only in the historical athar preceding the Hadith, where some narrators omit certain details or rephrase the description of the incident

I have explained this in the Table below


Read the reply of Sheikh Abdullah ibn Muhammad ibn al-Siddiq al-Ghumari, when Albani tried to weaken the narration of Uthman ibn Hunayf 

[Check out - Authentication of narration of Uthman ibn Hunayf [Waseela] : After the passing of RasoolAllah, LINK]

Overall Conclusion

Scholar's Authentication


Now let's see some scholars who graded this Narration of Abu Ayub al-Ansari رضي الله عنه as Authentic [Hasan/Sahih]

1) Imam Abu Abdullah al-Hakim [d.405 AH]

“This hadith has a sound [Sahih] chain of narration”

📚 Al-Mustadrak ala al-Sahihayn 8571, 4/560

2) Imam Shamsuddin al-Dhahabi [d.748 AH]

“Sahih”

📚 Talkhis al-Mustadrak 4/515

3) Imam Abul Fath al-Maraghi al-Madani [d.859 AH]

Imam Nuruddin al-Samhudi [d.911 AH] :

“Ahmad narrated with a Sound [Hasan] chain of transmission, as I saw it in the handwriting of the memorizer Abu al-Fath al-Maraghi al-Madani”

📚 Wafa' al-Wafa 5/46

4) Imam Nuruddin al-Samhudi [d.911 AH]

“I say : Ahmad narrated it with a Good [Hasan] chain of transmission”

📚 Khulasatul Wafa 1/457

5) Imam Jalaluddin al-Suyuti [d. 911 AH]

“Sahih”

📚 al-Jami al-Saghir 9728

6) Imam Muhammad ibn Yusuf al-Salihi [d.942 AH]

“Imam Ahmad narrated, with a good [Hasan] chain of transmission”

📚 Subul al-Huda 12/398


7) Imam Abdur Rauf al-Munawi [d.1031 AH]

“Reported by Ahmad on the authority of Abu Ayyub al-Ansari, and its chain of narration is good [Hasan]”

📚 al-Taysir 2/489

THERE ARE MANY MORE....